In August the Caribbean Court of Justice’s President answered public allegations about the Court’s internal affairs and issued a practice direction requiring every judge to sit on every panel; at home the month brought no Act, no Bill and no regulations of general application.
August was the thinnest month of the year for Guyanese legislation. The National Assembly passed no Act and published no Bill, and the weekly Legal Supplements of the Official Gazette record only a single land-acquisition order and a public-holiday notification by way of subsidiary legislation. The Caribbean Court of Justice delivered no new judgment in a Guyanese appeal. The month’s legal significance lay instead in the Court itself, the final court of appeal for Guyana, whose working methods became, unusually, a matter of public controversy.
On 14 August the President of the Court, Mr Justice Winston Anderson, issued a public statement, Media Release No. 31 of 2026, responding to what he described as recent press reports and publications concerning the internal affairs of the Court. He condemned, in the strongest terms, the unauthorised disclosure and publication of confidential material relating to the Court’s internal deliberations and correspondence, as striking at a fundamental principle on which judicial independence depends. He then addressed the allegations in turn, among them consultation with his colleagues, judicial dress, the composition of panels and suggestions of influence over judgments. He rejected entirely the suggestion that panels had been constituted or altered to secure predetermined outcomes. But he announced that, “to put this matter to rest”, every judge of the Court would in future be required to sit on every panel, unless excused for a legitimate reason.
Five days later that undertaking became a rule of practice. Practice Direction No. 1 of 2026, Panel Assignments, issued by the President under Part 18.1 of the Caribbean Court of Justice (Appellate Jurisdiction) Rules 2024 and Part 32.1 of the Original Jurisdiction Rules 2024, and announced by the Court on 19 August with immediate effect, provided that all panels in both jurisdictions — case management panels and hearing panels, on procedural and substantive matters alike — would sit en banc, comprising the President and all the judges. A judge wishing to recuse could be excused, in a procedural matter by a case management panel leader and in a substantive matter, including an application for special leave, by the President, with a record kept by the Registrar. The Direction did not apply to the powers exercisable by a single judge under the Rules.
For Guyanese litigants the practical consequences were immediate. Applications for special leave and interlocutory matters, as well as full appeals, would now come before the whole Court. That promised a uniform bench and removed any argument about who sat, but it also meant that every procedural step would require the attention of all seven judges. Practitioners with matters pending before the Court should have checked how the Direction applied to their case. Its life proved short; its withdrawal is discussed in the October docket.
There is a broader point. Guyana has made the Caribbean Court of Justice its final court of appeal, and the Court’s legitimacy rests in large part on public confidence in its collegiality and independence. The President’s statement, and the Court’s willingness to change its practice in response, are themselves developments of legal importance for every Guyanese litigant whose case may end in Port of Spain.
From the Guyana Courts
On 6 August Renita Singh J gave an early ruling on interim measures in aid of arbitration under the Arbitration Act 2024, in the dispute between the Austrian contractor VAMED Engineering GmbH and the Ministry of Health over the specialty hospitals at Ogle and New Amsterdam. As reported, she held that the court has jurisdiction under the Act to grant interim measures pending arbitration, but refused VAMED’s applications for conservatory and restraining orders because the urgency required for such relief had not been shown, and directed that the dispute proceed to arbitration. She nevertheless ordered both sides to preserve the project sites, the 52 containers of equipment at the Ogle site and the contractor’s documents, designs and intellectual property pending the appointment of a tribunal. The Full Court set the preservation orders aside in September.
On 24 August the High Court dismissed a claim by the People’s National Congress Reform arising from its removal from a building in Lethem that had served as its regional office for decades, holding that the land and building belonged to the State, vested in the Regional Democratic Council, and that long occupation without a lease or title gave the party no right to remain. On 27 August the Court of Appeal, comprising the acting Chancellor, Justice Roxane George, and Persaud and Harnanan JJA, directed that the extradition committal proceedings against Nazar and Azruddin Mohamed continue before the magistrate, but stayed the final disposition until their appeal on the constitutionality of the Fugitive Offenders Act is determined. And the High Court awarded a former Assistant Commissioner of Police, Paul Slowe, $1 million in damages for his wrongful arrest in the precincts of the Georgetown Magistrates’ Court in October 2021.
These accounts are taken from press reports and official statements and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. The arbitration, the PNCR’s announced appeal and the extradition appeal remain pending, and nothing here comments on their merits.
Also this month
At home, Order No. 171 of 2026, made by the Minister of Public Works under the Acquisition of Lands for Public Purposes Act, Cap. 62:05, and published in the Official Gazette of 8 August, declared a GPL transmission line and public road from Plantation T’Hust Te Coverden to the Soesdyke–Linden Highway, on the East Bank of Demerara, to be a public work. The schedule describes a strip about 600 feet wide and 15,500 feet long, passing through Plantations T’Hust Te Coverden, Den Heuvel and the northern half of Soesdyke and comprising some 195 acres. Owners along that corridor should take advice on the acquisition process and on compensation.
The jury lists for the three counties were gazetted on 1 August, and the boards of the Natural Resource Fund and its Investment Committee were reappointed on 20 August.
A month without new law at home was nonetheless a month of consequence for the final court that interprets it. The way a court organises itself is part of the justice it dispenses.
