The Court of Appeal set aside the ruling that ExxonMobil must provide an unlimited parent company guarantee for the Liza 1 project, and the Caribbean Court of Justice held that CARICOM free movement carries a minimum standard of human rights, including access to counsel, and awarded damages against Suriname; a Bill to create a National Sex Offender Database was published and digital identity cards became a recognised travel document.
No Act was passed in May, but the month produced the most important original-jurisdiction judgment of the year and, on its final working day, four Bills that would reshape parts of the criminal and commercial law. For Guyanese who travel, work and do business across the Community — and for the many CARICOM nationals who now do so in Guyana — the judgment is the place to begin.
On 25 May the Caribbean Court of Justice gave judgment in Ramsamooj v Suriname [2026] CCJ 2 (OJ). A Trinidadian political consultant was detained in Paramaribo in October 2020 in a fraud investigation and, under beperking orders made under article 40(2) of Suriname’s Code of Criminal Procedure, was denied direct access to a lawyer for two consecutive eight-day periods. During that time he was interrogated through an interpreter and signed a statement in Dutch that was later used as his confession. The Court held that Community law imposes minimum human rights standards that must attend the exercise of Treaty rights, without which free movement would be deprived of its effectiveness. Those standards include an accused person’s right of access to counsel of his or her choice, now entrenched in every member state’s constitution and crystallised, the Court said, into a regional customary standard.
The reasoning repays close attention. The Charter of Civil Society is not binding as a treaty, but it is an aid to interpreting the Revised Treaty and helps identify general principles of Community law. A claimant need not prove discrimination on the ground of nationality when the domestic law applied to him is itself incompatible with the minimum standard. And a member state will only in extremely rare circumstances be able to rely on the public-order exception in Article 226 to justify conduct under a domestic procedure that falls below that standard. The Court declared that the application of the beperking breached the claimant’s right to freedom of movement and awarded USD30,000 in non-pecuniary damages. It also declared that any use, in the pending criminal proceedings, of admissions obtained during the unlawful detention would breach Community law, though Suriname may proceed on untainted evidence.
For Guyana the lesson is direct. The right of an arrested person to retain and instruct a lawyer without delay is already guaranteed by article 139(3) of the Constitution; what the judgment adds is a second forum and a second remedy. Where a Community national exercising Treaty rights is held without access to counsel, the State’s exposure is no longer confined to the domestic courts. It may be answerable before the Caribbean Court of Justice for a breach of the Revised Treaty, and in damages. Police and prosecutors should treat early access to counsel as a Community obligation as well as a constitutional one.
The Bills came on 29 May. The Sexual Offences (Amendment) Bill 2026 (Bill No. 6 of 2026), presented by the Minister of Human Services and Social Security, would insert a new Part IXA into the Sexual Offences Act, Cap. 8:03, creating a National Sex Offender Database. Courts would be able to order persons convicted of listed offences after commencement to register and report to the police; registered offenders would have to notify changes of address within fourteen days and give at least seven days’ notice of foreign travel; institutions working with children or vulnerable adults could seek information on a specific offender; and victims would be notified of an offender’s impending release. Failure to make the initial report would be punishable by a fine of $500,000 and a year’s imprisonment, and offenders could apply to the High Court for expungement at the end of the reporting period. The Bill has since been sent to a select committee. Three other Bills published the same day — on hire-purchase, the sale of depreciating seized property, and the validation of security-interest registrations — were passed in July and are discussed in the July docket.
From the Guyana Courts
On 7 May the Court of Appeal, Gregory, Harnanan and Sewnarine-Beharry JJA, unanimously allowed the appeals of ExxonMobil Guyana Limited and the Environmental Protection Agency against Kissoon J’s 2023 judgment that the Liza 1 environmental permit required Exxon to provide an unlimited parent company guarantee of its liability for environmental damage, and that the permit be suspended until it did so. As reported, the Court held that, although Exxon is liable for any environmental damage its operations cause, unlimited liability and financial assurance are distinct concepts, and that the judge erred in conflating them. Neither the permit nor the Environmental Protection Act provides for an unlimited guarantee; on their correct interpretation, the permit required a guarantee in a definite amount, and the Agency had a discretion to accept one for a defined sum. The Agency and Exxon had not acted improperly in settling the guarantee at US$2 billion, and the judge had erred in substituting his own discretion for that of the body Parliament had charged with the decision. The Attorney General, joined as a party after the Caribbean Court of Justice’s 2024 decision noted in the May and July 2024 dockets, supported the appeals.
The decision brings to an end, subject to any further appeal, litigation that has shaped the regulation of offshore petroleum for several years and formed the background to the oil spill liability regime enacted in 2025 and discussed in the May 2025 docket. It also restates a familiar principle of administrative law: on review, the court asks whether the regulator acted lawfully, not whether it would have reached a different decision itself.
In the accounts closure litigation, the Full Court on 7 May dismissed, by a majority, Niles and Kumar-Chetty JJ, with Singh CJ (Ag) dissenting, Demerara Bank Ltd’s appeals against the refusal to strike out claims by candidates of We Invest in Nationhood whose accounts had been closed, holding that the claims disclosed an arguable case for breach of the banker-customer contract. Shortly afterwards the Court of Appeal, Barlow, Gregory and Khan JJA, refused a Brazilian gold dealer leave to appeal the Full Court’s December ruling that the Special Organised Crime Unit has capacity to bring proceedings under the Anti-Money Laundering and Countering the Financing of Terrorism Act. And Kumar-Chetty J ordered the Mayor and City Council to remove vendors from outside the Georgetown Public Hospital by the end of the month.
These accounts are taken from press reports and official statements and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. The account closure claims remain before the High Court, and nothing here comments on their merits.
Also this month
The Immigration (Alternative to Passports) (Amendment) Order 2026, Order No. 87 of 2026, made by the President on 15 May under section 5 of the Immigration Act, Cap. 14:02, and gazetted on 18 May, redefines “identification card” for the purposes of the principal Order to mean a digital identity card issued under the Digital Identity Card Act 2023, or under the corresponding law of a country listed in its Schedule. On 15 May, in Bennett v Government of the United States of America [2026] CCJ 7 (AJ) BZ, the Caribbean Court of Justice held that Belize’s lower courts had erred in relying on an interception statute that was not yet in force when they excluded WhatsApp messages in extradition proceedings, and remitted the constitutional questions to the High Court.
On 6 May the Bank of Guyana licensed OneAmericas Trade Finance Incorporated to carry on non-depository financial business, and approved a representative office for Citibank N.A., under the Financial Institutions Act; both notices were gazetted on 9 May. On 23 May the Integrity Commission published, under section 19 of its Act, the names of 231 specified persons in public life who had not filed their 2025 declarations, including former Members of Parliament, and set 22 June as the deadline before continued default became an offence. Orders Nos. 78 to 81 of 2026, gazetted on 2 May, declared further GPL transmission-line works to be public works with a view to acquiring land.
May’s judgment speaks to the conduct of the State; its Bills to the conduct of citizens. Both will reward careful reading by those who advise on the criminal process, at home and across the region.
