Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

Tenders, Arbitrators and the Second Chance to Plead

March 2026

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

Three judgments of the Caribbean Court of Justice in Guyanese appeals — recognising the tender “process contract”, refusing to treat an arbitrator who sits twice as automatically biased, and insisting that a defective pleading be given the chance of amendment — and the commencement of the Digital Identity Card Act 2023 made March a month of consequence for commercial practice.

No Act was passed in March. The month belonged to the Caribbean Court of Justice, which delivered three judgments in appeals from Guyana in a fortnight, each with something to say to those who tender, arbitrate or litigate here. The Court of Appeal also gave judgment in the most closely watched public-law case of the year, and a long-dormant statute on digital identity was brought into force.

The most significant of the three, for commercial lawyers, is Cara Investments Ltd v Ram [2026] CCJ 5 (AJ) GY, decided on 25 March. A receiver-manager appointed by the Bank of Nova Scotia over Hotel Tower Ltd invited proposals for the hotel’s assets in 1999. Cara submitted what it called an “expression of interest”, conditional on due diligence, and then sued before submitting a final bid. The Court unanimously dismissed the appeal. But Rajnauth-Lee J, delivering the lead judgment, held that the doctrine of the process contract — “Contract A”, familiar from Canadian law — should be recognised in Guyana, in private as well as public tendering, where the parties’ intention, objectively derived from the tender documents and surrounding circumstances, supports it. Formal, detailed and structured processes requiring significant expenditure by bidders will often point that way. Cara’s conditional proposal was not a bid capable of creating such a contract. Receivers in Guyana owe a statutory duty to act honestly and in good faith, but no breach was pleaded or proved. Jamadar J, concurring, located good faith among the fundamental norms of all commercial dealing. Anyone who runs a tender in Guyana, public or private, should now assume that its process may be contractually binding, and draft its documents accordingly.

On 11 March, in Attorney General of Guyana v Meerza [2026] CCJ 3 (AJ) GY, the Court dismissed the State’s appeal against the enforcement of an arbitral award of GYD179,946,850 for road works. The State argued that one arbitrator, having sat on an earlier panel whose award was not enforced, was apparently biased and should have disclosed his earlier role. The Court held that his prior involvement was no secret, so there was nothing to disclose, and that sitting again on the same dispute does not of itself give rise to apparent bias: “something additional of substance” is required. The State had also waited more than seven months to object, when the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules allow fifteen days, and had waived its objection. Parties who hold back an objection to see how an arbitration turns out should expect short shrift.

The third judgment, Panday v Panday [2026] CCJ 4 (AJ) GY, gave on 17 March the reasons for orders made on 17 December 2025. The courts below had struck out a partnership claim for disclosing no reasonable grounds. The Court held that striking out was premature, and set out a two-stage approach under the Civil Procedure Rules 2016: first, whether the claim discloses a cause of action and sufficient particulars; second, if a claim exists but is deficient, a balancing of resources, proportionality and fairness, and consideration of unless orders and costs before the claim is struck out. The matter was remitted to a different High Court judge. Defendants who apply to strike out should expect to be met with an offer to amend.

On 17 March the Court of Appeal, in a unanimous decision delivered by the Chancellor (Ag), dismissed the appeal of Nazar and Azruddin Mohamed against the refusal of judicial review of the Minister’s authority to proceed with their extradition. It held that the Minister was exercising an administrative function to which the rule against bias did not apply. On 25 March the Caribbean Court of Justice granted an interim stay of the extradition proceedings pending its own decision; the final outcome is discussed in the July docket.

From the Guyana Courts

On 5 March Younge J dismissed an application by Nazar and Azruddin Mohamed to restore the foreign exchange dealer’s licence revoked by the Bank of Guyana after their designation by the United States Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control in June 2024. As reported, the judge held that the Dealers in Foreign Currency (Licensing) Act allows the Bank, after consultation with the Minister, to consider the character and antecedents of a licensee; that the Bank had every right to take the applicants’ sanctioned status into account; and that, having found them no longer fit and proper, it was empowered to revoke the licence. She rejected the contention that the decision had been predetermined. The ruling confirms that a foreign sanctions designation may properly bear on fitness to hold a financial licence in Guyana.

On 27 March Corbin-Lincoln J restrained a private university from carrying out construction works at the Critchlow Labour College on Woolford Avenue pending trial of a dispute over whether the college’s principal had authority to grant it a lease, and whether the lease was made while the college company stood struck off the register.

On 30 March Pierre J gave judgment in four claims against the Guyana Bank for Trade and Industry Ltd by candidates of We Invest in Nationhood whose accounts the bank had closed after the party’s leader was designated by the United States Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control. As reported, the judge accepted that the bank was entitled to manage sanctions-related risk as a legitimate commercial objective, but held that it had exercised its contractual power to terminate the accounts arbitrarily, in breach of implied terms requiring honesty, good faith and rationality: the decisions rested not on conduct or evidence specific to each customer but on a generalised assumption arising from association with the party, made without inquiry and without considering less intrusive measures. Each claimant was awarded $20,000 in damages and $300,000 in costs. The judge rejected the claims founded on procedural fairness and natural justice, holding that the decisions arose under a private contract and were not amenable to public law review, and dismissed the claims under the Prevention of Discrimination Act and the Anti-Money Laundering and Countering the Financing of Terrorism Act as disclosing no private cause of action. She also declined to make declarations about the legal status of the party and the reach of the sanctions.

These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. These matters remain before the courts, including on appeal, and nothing here comments on their merits.

Also this month

By the Digital Identity Card Act 2023 (Commencement) Order 2026, Order No. 73 of 2026, made by the Prime Minister on 24 March and gazetted on 26 March, the Digital Identity Card Act 2023, Act No. 19 of 2023, came into operation on 31 March 2026. The Act establishes a Digital Identity Card Registry, administered by the Data Protection Commissioner, to collect identity data of citizens aged fourteen and over, of CARICOM skilled nationals and of other non-citizens permitted to work in Guyana, and to issue citizen and non-citizen digital identity cards. Employers of foreign and CARICOM workers should expect the card to become part of their onboarding. The Income Tax (General) (Amendment) Regulations 2026, Regulations No. 4 of 2026, gazetted on 11 March, substituted new prescribed income tax return forms.

By Orders Nos. 15 to 72 of 2026, made on 20 and 24 March by the Minister of Public Works under section 3(2) of the Roads Act, Cap. 51:01, and published in the Official Gazettes of 21 and 28 March, a long list of Georgetown streets was declared to be public roads. And on 5 March the Bank of Guyana designated Green Trade Imports Inc. a credit information provider under the Credit Reporting Act 2010, by notice published on 14 March.

Each of March’s three judgments rewards a party that conducts itself carefully: the bidder that submits a real bid, the party that objects promptly, the litigant that pleads a real case. Each penalises the opposite. Those are lessons worth carrying into every tender, arbitration and statement of claim.