Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

Bad Debts Before the Revenue, a Gas-to-Shore Road and Res Ipsa Loquitur

March 2025

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The High Court set aside tax assessments against two banks because the Revenue had disclosed no method for disallowing their bad and doubtful debts, land along the route from Golden Grove to Land of Canaan was declared needed for a four-lane public road, a courthouse opened at Friendship, and the Caribbean Court of Justice confirmed that res ipsa loquitur need not be specifically pleaded; the Court also farewelled one judge and named another.

March 2025 was a quiet month in the Official Gazette, with no Acts and no Bills. Its most consequential instrument concerned land. The Acquisition of Lands for Public Purposes (GAS to Shore Route) Order 2025, Order No. 9 of 2025, published on 22 March and made under sections 3 and 4 of the Acquisition of Lands for Public Purposes Act, Cap. 62:05, declares the proposed construction of a four-lane public road from the rear of Golden Grove to Land of Canaan, both on the East Bank of Demerara, to be a public work. The schedule describes a strip 600 feet wide, about 500 acres in extent, by reference to plan COS 1658. The Commissioner of Lands and Surveys and those acting with him are authorised to enter the lands to survey and examine them with a view to acquiring the whole or part.

An order of this kind is the first formal step in compulsory acquisition. It does not of itself transfer title, but it signals to owners and occupiers along the route that acquisition, and the statutory process for compensation, are likely to follow. Those with interests in the affected lands, whether as owners, lessees, mortgagees or occupiers, should identify their parcels against the schedule and the plan, keep records of the land’s present condition and use, and be ready to assert their claims when notices are served.

A second land matter appeared in the same issue. The Commissioner of the Guyana Lands and Surveys Commission gave first notice of a proposal to cancel State Land Lease No. A-26544, held by the Urban Dairy Cattle Farmers Association, covering 499.880 acres at portions of Plantations Tyd-en-Vlyt and Hoogs Bosch, East Bank Demerara, so that the land could be repossessed for reallocation. Objectors were invited to write to the Commissioner within seven days of the third publication. Notices of this kind are easily missed, and the short window for objections makes it important that lessees of State land monitor the Gazette.

Access to justice on the East Bank also improved. By a legal notice dated 24 March and published on 29 March, the Chancellor of the Judiciary (ag.), Justice Yonette Cummings-Edwards, acting under section 58 of the Summary Jurisdiction (Magistrates) Act, Cap. 3:05, declared a building at Tract ‘X’, Parcel 6, Plantation Friendship, East Bank Demerara, a courthouse for the Friendship Magistrate’s Court, with sittings from 31 March.

In the Caribbean Court of Justice, Sandy Lane Hotel Co Ltd v Eversley [2025] CCJ 5 (AJ) BB, decided on 18 March, is a Barbadian appeal with obvious relevance here. A housekeeper was injured when a piece of marble above a hotel room doorway fell on her. Burgess J, giving the judgment of the Court, held that res ipsa loquitur is not a distinct rule of law but a process of inferential reasoning, with the burden of proof remaining on the claimant throughout; that it need not be specifically pleaded where the statement of claim sets out the necessary facts; and that the introduction of the Civil Procedure Rules did not change the common law on this point. The Court also reaffirmed that it will review concurrent findings of fact of the courts below only in exceptional circumstances. Guyana’s Civil Procedure Rules 2016 follow the same model, and the reasoning will be persuasive in personal injury claims here.

From the Guyana Courts

On 17 March, in two tax appeals heard together, Guyana Bank for Trade and Industry Ltd v Commissioner-General of the Guyana Revenue Authority (Action No. 2023-HC-DEM-CIV-FDA-283) and Republic Bank (Guyana) Ltd v Commissioner-General of the Guyana Revenue Authority (Action No. 2023-HC-DEM-CIV-FDA-282), Corbin-Lincoln J, sitting in the Commercial Court on appeals to a judge in chambers under section 86 of the Income Tax Act, set aside corporation tax assessments raised against the two banks for years of assessment between 2011 and 2017. The assessments rested largely on the Commissioner-General’s disallowance of the deductions the banks had claimed for bad and doubtful debts under section 16(1)(e) of the Act, which they had classified in accordance with international standards and the Bank of Guyana’s Supervisory Guideline No. 5.

In the GBTI appeal the judge first settled the scope of the proceedings. An appeal on the ground that an assessment is excessive is a challenge to quantum, in the nature of a fresh hearing, and is distinct from judicial review; declarations such as a breach of legitimate expectation fall outside it. Although the Act places on the taxpayer the burden of proving that an assessment is excessive, she preferred the approach in Argosy that the Commissioner-General also bears an evidential burden to show the grounds on which he acted. An “additional assessment” for 2011 failed at the threshold: there was no evidence of any original assessment, so it could not have “appeared” to the Commissioner-General under section 72 that the bank had been under-assessed.

On the central issue, the judge accepted that the Commissioner-General is not bound by guidelines issued by another statutory body, but held that he must have criteria of his own “in the interest of good administration transparency and fairness”. Section 16(2) allows the Minister to make regulations prescribing how deductions are to be calculated or estimated; none has been made, and the Authority has published no guidelines. In their absence the Commissioner-General cannot apply unidentified standards, or none at all, and must act in accordance with an identified and recognised industry standard or practice and disclose the methodology used. Because none was disclosed, although the bank had supplied the information requested, the disallowances were unreasonable and arbitrary, the assessments made “according to his judgment” did not rest on a rational opinion based on the information available, and the assessments, including those maintained or amended after objection, were excessive, null and void. Costs of $1.5 million were awarded. The Republic Bank appeal, covering 2011, 2012 and 2014 to 2017, was allowed on the same day.

The rulings reach beyond the two banks. Every lender that provisions for loan losses under the Bank of Guyana’s guidelines meets the same question when its taxable income is computed, and until regulations are made under section 16(2), or the Authority publishes criteria of its own, these judgments supply the test by which disallowances of bad and doubtful debts will be measured. The Authority filed appeals to the Full Court in April but discontinued them in May.

In a judgment reported on 26 March, Morris J dismissed an application for judicial review of the environmental impact assessment for ExxonMobil Guyana’s Hammerhead project, but, according to the applicants, accepted their central argument: that the carbon dioxide emitted when the oil produced is eventually burned, the so-called scope 3 emissions, is an indirect effect of the project that the assessment must address. The remedies sought were refused in part because the Environmental Protection Agency had changed the terms and scope of the assessment after the claim was filed, and the Hammerhead assessment now includes greenhouse gas impacts. The approach accords with that of the United Kingdom Supreme Court in R (Finch) v Surrey County Council in 2024. Petroleum developers should expect future assessments to be tested against it; the production licence for Hammerhead, granted in September, is noted in that month’s docket.

Three other rulings are worth recording. On 4 March George CJ (Ag) declared two small miners the lawful owners of 32 gold claims at Issano and quashed an order of the Guyana Geology and Mines Commission requiring them to remove from the claim area, together with related ministerial directives. In mid-March the Chief Justice held that the 2020 termination of the Chief Executive Officer of the Central Housing and Planning Authority on one month’s notice was unlawful and ordered that he be paid for the remaining 29 months of his three-year contract. And on 31 March Niles J refused a social media commentator’s application to set aside the $52 million defamation judgment entered against him in July 2024 in favour of Nazar and Azruddin Mohamed.

The account of the bank tax appeals is taken from the written judgment and the court filings. The other accounts are taken from press reports and statements by the parties and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment in those matters has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of any of these matters.

Also this month

On 18 March the Caribbean Court of Justice held a special sitting to mark the retirement of Mr Justice Andrew Burgess, the first Barbadian appointed to its bench, who retired on 11 April. On 24 March the Court announced that the Regional Judicial and Legal Services Commission had selected Dr Chile Eboe-Osuji of Nigeria and Canada to fill the vacancy. In aviation, the Civil Aviation (Amendment) Requirements for Air Traffic Services 2025, Requirements No. 5 of 2025, made by the Guyana Civil Aviation Authority on 24 March, amended the separation standards in the Civil Aviation Requirements for Air Traffic Services 2024.

A month without legislation is not a month without law. For landowners on the East Bank, the GAS to Shore Route Order may prove to be the most important notice of the year.