Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

Who Is an Elected Member, the CLICO Bailout and Delay in Criminal Appeals

October 2024

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The Caribbean Court of Justice decided who counts as an elected member of the National Assembly, dismissed the claim by BAICO policyholders over Trinidad and Tobago’s CLICO bailout, and considered delay in two Barbadian criminal appeals; the Anna Regina Magistrate’s Court moved temporarily to Suddie.

On 30 October the Caribbean Court of Justice delivered judgment in Attorney General v Jones [2024] CCJ 20 (AJ) GY. The case concerned two persons named on the list of candidates of the governing party at the 2020 elections whose names were not among those extracted to fill the party’s seats, and who were later appointed Parliamentary Secretaries by the President under article 186 of the Constitution. The respondent had obtained declarations in the High Court that they were not lawful members of the National Assembly. Both the High Court and the Court of Appeal considered themselves bound by the earlier High Court decision in Attorney General v Morian, which had in turn followed Trotman v Attorney General.

The CCJ allowed the appeal and vacated the orders below. On precedent, it held that where a Court of Appeal disposes of an appeal on purely procedural grounds without assessing the trial judge’s reasoning, a later appellate court should be very hesitant to treat itself as bound by that reasoning; the Court of Appeal had been free to evaluate Morian for itself. On the substance, the Court held that an elected member of the National Assembly is a member whose name has been extracted from a successful list. Morian had created two classes of “elected members”, one able to sit and vote and the other not, with untenable consequences across the Constitution, including the absurdity that an unextracted candidate might be appointed Prime Minister without being accountable to the Assembly. Unextracted candidates are not elected members; but provided they remain qualified to be elected, they are eligible, like any other qualified citizen, to be appointed among the limited number of non-elected Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries, in which case they may sit in the Assembly but may not vote. Because the appeal resolved a constitutional question of public importance, each party bore its own costs. The Court observed that the issue had posed challenges in the past, and its answer will govern the composition of the Assembly and appointments to office after future elections.

The composition of the National Assembly is a matter of political sensitivity, and nothing here comments on matters beyond the judgment itself.

On 22 October the CCJ, in its original jurisdiction, dismissed the claim in Richards v Trinidad and Tobago [2024] CCJ 2 (OJ). The claimants, nationals of Antigua and Barbuda and Grenada, held policies with British American Insurance Company Ltd, a Bahamian subsidiary of CL Financial, and complained that Trinidad and Tobago’s rescue of CLICO and British American Insurance Company (Trinidad) Ltd after the 2009 collapse had protected Trinidadian policyholders but not them. The Court held that article 184(1)(j) of the Revised Treaty, on consumer protection, did not create liability for an individual Member State in these circumstances, and that article 7, on non-discrimination, is not a free-standing provision but must be linked to a Treaty right. In any event the circumstances of the policyholders of the rescued Trinidadian companies were not comparable, and the bailout had an objective and reasonable justification in containing systemic risk to the economy of Trinidad and Tobago.

From the Guyana Courts

Sitting in the Constitutional and Administrative Division, Corbin-Lincoln J, in a ruling reported on 8 October, quashed the Trade Union Recognition and Certification Board’s certification of the Guyana Agricultural and General Workers Union as bargaining agent for workers at the Guyana Rice Development Board. As reported, the Board was required to have regard to the views of the competing Union of Agricultural and Allied Workers and exceeded its authority by certifying the applicant without adequately considering them. The membership survey and poll were annulled, and the competing union was held entitled to the survey results.

On 22 October Pierre J ordered the publishers of the Guyana Chronicle to pay $700,000 in damages to a former Mayor of Georgetown, Ubraj Narine, for a report that attributed to him remarks that had in fact been directed at another official. Applying Reynolds v Times Newspapers and Lange v Atkinson, the judge held that the statutory privilege for fair and accurate reports under section 14 of the Defamation Act was not available: the report was inaccurate, little had been done to verify it, the claimant’s side had not been sought, and allegations were presented as fact. The judgment is a useful restatement of what responsible journalism requires.

These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of either matter.

Also this month

On 17 October the CCJ decided two Barbadian criminal appeals in which delay was a central complaint. In Weekes v The State [2024] CCJ 18 (AJ) BB the appeal was dismissed and the conviction and sentence upheld. In Harewood v The State [2024] CCJ 19 (AJ) BB the Court found significant and even unacceptable periods of delay, including fifteen months to deliver judgment on appeal, but held that on the evidence the delay did not cross the threshold of constitutional unreasonableness. The judgments are a reminder that a complaint of delay must be supported by evidence of its causes and its effects.

By a legal notice dated 29 October under section 58 of the Summary Jurisdiction (Magistrates) Act, the Chancellor of the Judiciary (ag.) directed that from 30 October all sittings of the Anna Regina Magistrate’s Court would be held at the Suddie Magistrate’s Court until further notice, to allow the old courthouse to be demolished while a new one is built. Cabinet appointed the Rice Assessment Committee for 2025, published on 8 October, and a further series of National Industrial and Commercial Investments Limited (Transfer of Property) Orders, Nos. 68 to 78 of 2024, was published on 12 and 18 October.