Two condominium schemes were approved under the Condominium Act 2022, a Central Authority was established for intercountry adoption under the Hague Convention, and the Caribbean Court of Justice gave its reasons on pension and severance after a wrongful dismissal.
The Official Gazette of 9 March 2024 carried two orders made by the Minister of Housing and Water, Hon. Collin Croal, under section 5 of the Condominium Act 2022. Order No. 10 of 2024 declared that the requirements of a condominium scheme had been satisfied and that approval of the proposed declaration and proposed description had been granted for Atlantic Towers, submitted by Visionary Investment Inc. in respect of Lots 138, 168 and 169, Section L, Campbellville, Georgetown. Order No. 11 of 2024 did the same for Shorelines Estates, submitted by Atlantic Builders Inc. in respect of Plot ‘A’, the eastern part of Tract ‘X’, Plantation Hope, a portion of the frontlands of Enmore Estate, East Coast Demerara. Both approvals were granted on 4 March 2024.
The Condominium Act 2022 introduced to Guyana a statutory framework for the ownership of individual units in a building or development, with common elements held and managed collectively. Ministerial approval under section 5 is the gateway to the scheme: once the declaration and description are approved and registered, units can be separately owned, mortgaged and transferred, and the condominium corporation takes on responsibility for the common elements. For purchasers and lenders the practical lesson is that the declaration, the description and the by-laws deserve the same careful review as a title, since they govern the use of units, the sharing of common expenses and the rules of the community.
Published on 6 March, and made by the Minister of Human Services and Social Security, Dr the Hon. Vindhya Vasini Persaud, was the Guyana Central Authority for Hague Conventions Matters (Establishment) Order 2024, Order No. 14 of 2024, made under section 35C of the Adoption of Children Act, Cap. 46:04. It established the Central Authority of Guyana for the purposes of the Hague Convention of 29 May 1993 on Protection of Children and Co-operation in Respect of Intercountry Adoption, the text of which is scheduled to the Act. The Authority is chaired by the Minister and has five other members: an attorney-at-law of at least five years’ standing, two persons nominated by organisations concerned with the welfare and safety of children, and public officers nominated by the ministers responsible for home affairs and for foreign affairs. It must notify the Permanent Bureau of the Hague Conference of its designation. The Convention depends on a functioning Central Authority in each State, and the Order is the machinery through which adoptions between Guyana and other Convention States must now pass. The Hague Convention on the protection of children, which Parliament addressed in 2025, built on the same foundation.
On 19 March the Caribbean Court of Justice gave its reasons in Arjoon v New Building Society Ltd [2024] CCJ 7 (AJ) GY, an appeal it had allowed by order of 23 October 2023. The appellant had been dismissed as chief executive for alleged serious misconduct some six months before his scheduled retirement. The Court was unanimous that he had been wrongfully dismissed and was entitled to full pension benefits, as the trial judge had ordered, rather than merely the pooled contributions allowed by the Court of Appeal. On severance, the Court divided three to two. The majority held that, since he was to be treated for pension purposes as having involuntarily retired, he could not also recover severance pay under the Termination of Employment and Severance Pay Act; the statute did not intend that an employee should receive both. Employers and trustees of occupational pension schemes should read the judgment closely, since it treats a wrongful dismissal near retirement as giving rise to pension entitlement under the scheme rules.
From the Guyana Courts
In March George CJ (Ag) dismissed an application by the Director of Public Prosecutions to have the former Minister of Finance, Winston Jordan, committed for trial for misconduct in public office after a magistrate had discharged him at the end of the preliminary inquiry. The charge concerned the 2020 sale of State waterfront lands at Kingston to BK Marine Inc., which the prosecution said had been sold at a gross undervalue. The Director had sought an order without hearing Mr Jordan. As reported, the Chief Justice, for different reasons from the magistrate’s, agreed that the prosecution had not shown sufficient prima facie evidence to justify committal.
On 14 March Persaud J gave judgment for the Minister of Public Works, Bishop Juan Edghill, in a libel claim dating from a 2011 television commentary made when he chaired the Ethnic Relations Commission. The commentator was ordered to pay $15 million in compensatory damages, and the owner of the station that broadcast it $250,000 in nominal damages, with costs against both. A defamation claim that takes thirteen years to reach judgment is a reminder of how slowly such litigation can move.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of either matter.
Also this month
In Betancourt v The King [2024] CCJ 6 (AJ) BZ, decided on 8 March, the CCJ dismissed an appeal against a murder conviction in a judge-alone trial in Belize. The Court considered the argument that, having rejected the accused’s account of self-defence, the trial judge was bound to consider self-defence on a third version of events said to have emerged in cross-examination of a prosecution witness, and dismissed the appeal. The case is a useful reference on how far a judge sitting alone must address possible defences not advanced by the accused.
The orders of March were a reminder that property law and family law continue to be modernised in parallel with the larger economic legislation.
