Parliament passed the 2024 budget and a Fiscal Enactments Act that raised the income tax threshold, replaced the formula for withdrawals from the Natural Resource Fund and doubled the statutory borrowing limits; a civil aviation bill was published.
The National Assembly passed the Appropriation Act 2024, Act No. 1 of 2024, on 2 February, and it was published in the Extraordinary Gazette of 6 February. It authorised aggregate expenditure of $1,080,508,637,209 for the fiscal year ending 31 December 2024, crossing the one-trillion-dollar mark.
Passed on the same day and published on the same date was the Fiscal Enactments (Amendment) Act 2024, Act No. 2 of 2024, which carried the budget’s legal changes. For individuals, the income tax threshold was raised from $1,020,000 to $1,200,000 a year with effect from the 2024 year of income, the limit on the deduction for insurance premiums under section 16 of the Income Tax Act was raised from $360,000 to $600,000, and the related figure in sections 36 and 36A was increased from $2,040,000 to $2,400,000. Fire extinguishers and smoke alarms were zero-rated for VAT, sports equipment and mobile phones and their accessories were exempted, and a series of customs changes took effect from 2 February. Employers and payroll providers will have adjusted their withholding from the start of the year of income.
The most closely watched provision concerned the Natural Resource Fund Act 2021. The Act substituted a new First Schedule setting the ceiling on annual withdrawals from the Fund, other than for emergency financing, by reference to the deposits paid into the Fund in the preceding fiscal year. The ceiling is calculated on a sliding scale: 100 per cent of the first US$1 billion of deposits, 95 per cent of the second billion, 90 per cent of the third, 85 per cent of the fourth, 50 per cent of the fifth, and 10 per cent of anything above US$5 billion. Where the actual figure for the previous year is not available when the budget is presented, the best estimate is to be used. The formula determines how much of each year’s petroleum revenue may be brought into the budget and how much must be saved. Whether the balance it strikes is right is a matter of public debate; the legal point is that the ceiling is now fixed in the statute itself and can only be changed by Parliament.
This is a matter of public and political debate, and nothing here comments on the policy choices involved.
The Act also raised the statutory limits on government borrowing. The limit under the External Loans Act was raised from $900 billion to $1.5 trillion, and the limit under the Public Loans Act from $750 billion to $1.5 trillion. These limits are the outer bounds within which the government may contract loans without returning to the Assembly for a further increase.
The Civil Aviation (Amendment) Bill 2024, Bill No. 3 of 2024, was published on 2 February. It brought the Civil Aviation Act 2018 into line with changes to the international standards of the International Civil Aviation Organization, including a new section 42A permitting the emergency suspension of aviation documents and a new section 45A giving effect to Article 83 bis of the Chicago Convention, under which responsibility for oversight of an aircraft can be transferred between States where it is leased across borders. The Bill was passed on 9 May and became Act No. 4 of 2024; the regulations and requirements made under it are noted in the May docket.
From the Guyana Courts
The month’s most important decision came on 12 February, when George CJ (Ag) held that section 14 of the Matrimonial Causes Act, Cap. 45:02, was unconstitutional to the extent that, on a decree of divorce or nullity, it allowed the court to order only a former husband to pay maintenance or a lump sum to a former wife, and never the reverse. The claim was brought by a former husband who had been told that the law gave him no right to apply. As reported, the Chief Justice held that the provision discriminated on the grounds of sex and gender, contrary to articles 149 and 149D of the Constitution, and ordered that, until the National Assembly made adequate provision, section 14 be modified to permit applications by either a husband or a wife. Parliament did legislate: the amendment discussed in the August docket gave effect to the ruling by making maintenance available to either spouse.
In the teachers’ dispute, Kissoon J on 22 February granted the Guyana Teachers’ Union interim orders restraining the Government from deducting the salaries of teachers then on strike and from discontinuing the deduction and remittance of union dues, pending determination of the union’s claim. A week later the judge referred the dispute to mediation before two Senior Counsel. The substantive judgment followed in April.
Two other rulings concerned public office and public records. On 6 February George CJ (Ag) dismissed a challenge to the extension of the Commissioner of Police in office beyond the retirement age of fifty-five, which the President had granted on the recommendation of the Police Service Commission under section 2 of the Constitution (Prescribed Matters) Act, Cap. 27:12. On 19 February Persaud JA held that the Court of Appeal had no jurisdiction, on a summons in the pending appeal over the Liza 1 environmental permit, to order the Environmental Protection Agency to produce the US$2 billion parent company guarantee that the Court had earlier required ExxonMobil Guyana to lodge. And on 26 February Younge J held that the Agency was not obliged to require a fresh environmental impact assessment before renewing the Liza 1 environmental permit, reading the Environmental Protection Act and the Environmental Authorisations Regulations as a whole: whether a project requires an assessment is, in the first place, for the Agency.
These accounts are taken from press reports and official statements and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. The teachers’ case and the Liza 1 appeal then remained before the courts, and nothing here comments on their merits.
Also this month
The Acquisition of Lands for Public Purposes (New Demerara River Crossing and Connecting Road) Order 2024, Order No. 13 of 2024, was published on 10 February. Together with other orders made during the year, it continued the acquisition of land for the new Demerara River bridge and its approach roads and for new four-lane road corridors. Landowners affected by such orders should note the changes to the compensation regime made by the amending Act passed in December and discussed in that month’s docket.
In the Caribbean Court of Justice, Elrington v Progresso Heights Ltd [2024] CCJ 4 (AJ) BZ, decided on 20 February, dismissed an appeal by a 20 per cent shareholder who had lodged cautions against land owned by the company. The courts below had held that he had no unregistrable interest in the land of the kind the Registered Land Act requires before a caution may be lodged, and that the cautions had to be removed.
A budget of this size is above all a test of execution and of accountability, and the statutes that frame it are worth reading in full.
