The ICJ ordered Venezuela to refrain from any action that would modify the situation in Essequibo. The Court of Appeal upheld the dismissal of Election Petition No. 88. The CCJ restored a will to probate, delivered its first Saint Lucia judgment and reopened an extradition application. A Bill to introduce plea and assistance agreements was published, and constitutional office holders received a 6.5 per cent increase.
The Criminal Procedure (Plea Discussion, Plea Agreement and Assistance Agreement) Bill 2023 (Bill No. 19, 11 December) would establish a system of plea discussions, plea agreements and assistance agreements in criminal procedure. It has 38 clauses in five Parts and would come into force on a date appointed by the Minister. The Sea and River Defence Bill 2023 (Bill No. 21, 13 December) would repeal and replace the existing sea and river defence legislation and provide for the construction and maintenance of sea, river and natural defences. The Supplementary Appropriation (No. 3 for 2023) Bill (Bill No. 20) was published on 11 December and gazetted as Act No. 20 of 2023 on 20 December. The Arbitration Bill 2023 (Bill No. 18), published on 8 December according to the Parliament's records and read a first time on 11 December, would facilitate domestic and international arbitration by encouraging its use as a method of resolving disputes.
On 12 December the Ministers, Members of the National Assembly and Special Offices (Emoluments) Order 2023 (Order No. 75) and the Constitutional Offices (Remuneration of Holders) Order 2023 (Order No. 76) increased the salaries in the Schedules to the respective Acts by six and a half per cent, with effect from 1 January 2023. Acquisition orders were published for the Schoonord to Nouvelle Flanders road (Order No. 82, 27 December) and the GPL transmission line (Order No. 77, 30 December).
On 1 December the International Court of Justice unanimously indicated provisional measures in the case concerning the Arbitral Award of 3 October 1899. Pending its final decision, Venezuela must refrain from taking any action that would modify the situation prevailing in the territory in dispute, which Guyana administers and controls. Both parties must refrain from any action that might aggravate or extend the dispute or make it more difficult to resolve. The Court relied on official Venezuelan statements and reported military measures. It found a serious risk that Venezuela would acquire and exercise control over the territory, with a real and imminent risk of irreparable prejudice to the right claimed by Guyana that the Court found plausible. It emphasised that the validity of the 1899 Award is for the merits. On 14 December the Presidents of Guyana and Venezuela met in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines and issued the Joint Declaration of Argyle for Dialogue and Peace between Guyana and Venezuela. They agreed that neither State would, directly or indirectly, threaten or use force against the other, and that any controversies between them would be resolved in accordance with international law, including the Geneva Agreement of 1966.
The CCJ gave three judgments. In Persaud v Mongroo [2023] CCJ 16 (AJ) GY (15 December), a Georgetown businessman had made a will days before his death in 2010, appointing his business manager as executor and principal beneficiary. His daughters challenged it, alleging that he had not signed it and lacked capacity. The CCJ set aside the Court of Appeal's decision, restored George J's judgment, and admitted a copy of the will to probate in solemn form. In McDowall Broadcasting Corp Ltd v Joseph [2023] CCJ 15 (AJ) LC (8 December), its first judgment on appeal from Saint Lucia, the Court considered prescription under the Civil Code. It held that improper service was waived when the defendant acknowledged service and filed a defence, and refused special leave with costs. In Tasker v United States of America [2023] CCJ 14 (AJ) BB (7 December), a five-judge panel reopened the July refusal of special leave. It held that the Barbados Court of Appeal had erred in thinking it had no discretion and remitted the matter for that court to decide whether to treat the notice of appeal as an application for leave or to extend time.
From the Guyana Courts
On 18 December the Court of Appeal (Cummings-Edwards C (ag), Gregory-Barnes and Persaud JJA) unanimously dismissed the appeal in Thorne and Bostwick v Lowenfield. The Court upheld the Chief Justice (ag)'s earlier ruling that Election Petition No. 88 lacked merit. The Chief Justice had held that article 162 of the Constitution empowered GECOM to take the action needed to conclude the 2020 elections, including the recount under Order No. 60, and that the petitioners had not shown unlawful acts affecting the result.
On 11 December an Opposition MP filed a constitutional claim seeking 15 declarations and conservatory orders requiring the State to establish the Human Rights Commission. She also claimed that a statement by the Vice President about her breached her right to equal status. The Attorney General and the Leader of the Opposition are the respondents.
On 27 December a magistrate dismissed charges against six retired and three serving senior police officers of conspiring to defraud the Guyana Police Force of $10,056,000 over a 2018 review of the Force's Standing Orders, finding that the prosecution's evidence contradicted its own case.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of matters still pending.
Also this month
On 5 December an electronic Court Case Management System was launched as a pilot at the Diamond/Grove Magistrates' Court. Rex McKay SC, honoured in September by the CCJ Academy for Law, died in December at the age of 95 (reported 21 December).
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
