In two written judgments the Chief Justice (ag) dismissed a challenge to the appointment of the acting Commissioner of Police and upheld the appointments of the Police Service Commission Chairman and the Integrity Commission. She held, however, that the Police Service Commission is not duly constituted while the Public Service Commission has no Chairman. The CCJ quashed one of the two convictions in the Neesa Gopaul murder case. Industrial hemp was legalised under licence.
Five Acts were published on 11 August. The Supplementary Appropriation (No. 1 for 2022) Act 2022 (Act No. 10) and the Fiscal Enactments (Amendment) (No. 2) Act 2022 (Act No. 11) enact the July Bills; Act No. 11 enacts Bill No. 16 and in general takes effect from 1 January 2022. The Industrial Hemp Act 2022 (Act No. 13) enacts the May Bill. It removes industrial hemp dealt with under the Act from the prohibitions of the narcotics legislation and establishes a regulatory authority. The Anti-Money Laundering and Countering the Financing of Terrorism (Amendment) Act 2022 (Act No. 12) contains the changes intended to qualify the Financial Intelligence Unit for the Egmont Group. The Medical Practitioners (Amendment) Act 2022 (Act No. 15) removes the citizenship, residence and CARICOM nationality requirement for registration as a medical practitioner.
The Statistics (Population and Housing Census) Order 2022 (Order No. 34) and accompanying Regulations (No. 19), both of 12 August, fixed 15 September 2022 as census day. The National Registration (Claims and Objections) Order 2022 (Order No. 35) provided for a claims and objections period by reference to the qualifying date of 31 October 2022. Under Regulations No. 21 of 2022 (25 August), a person not resident in Guyana may drive for 60 days after entry without a local licence if he holds a valid licence from his country of residence and documents showing his date of entry. Amendments to the income tax, travel tax and travel voucher tax regulations (Regulations Nos. 16 to 18) were published on 5 August. The income tax and travel tax changes prescribe new forms and, for returns already filed on those forms, are deemed to have taken effect in January 2022.
On 19 August the CCJ decided Small v The State and Gopaul v The State [2022] CCJ 14 (AJ) GY. The appeals concerned the 2010 murder of 16-year-old Neesa Gopaul. In a judgment delivered in two parts by Barrow and Jamadar JJCCJ, the majority held that the evidence against Jarvis Small was insufficient. The trial judge should have upheld his submission of no case to answer, and should have ordered separate trials. A cell-mate's account of a confession by the co-accused was inadmissible against him and gravely prejudicial. His conviction was quashed. Bibi Gopaul's appeal against conviction was dismissed. Her sentence, which the Court of Appeal had reduced to 45 years, was replaced by 30 years with no eligibility for parole before 15 years, less five years for time on remand. Wit JCCJ, dissenting, would have held both convictions unsafe.
In Sears v Parole Board [2022] CCJ 13 (AJ) BZ (reasons, 5 August) the CCJ explained its earlier order releasing a parolee. He had been returned to prison in 2014 on suspicion of a drug transaction, and his parole was then revoked on the basis of a urine test. The Court held that the reincarceration breached his right to personal liberty, and that the revocation breached that right and his right to the equal protection of the law under the Constitution of Belize.
From the Guyana Courts
On 11 August the Chief Justice (ag) dismissed Christopher Jones MP's challenge to the appointment of Clifton Hicken as acting Commissioner of Police. She held that, when the appointment was made, there was no Leader of the Opposition and no Police Service Commission to consult, so consultation was impossible. She found the application vexatious and an abuse of process, refused relief and awarded costs. Even if the appointment had been unlawful, his acts would have been saved.
In the Leader of the Opposition's claim, decided on 23 August, she held that the President had consulted meaningfully on the appointment of Patrick Findlay as Chairman of the Police Service Commission and on the Integrity Commission, so those reliefs were refused. However, article 210 of the Constitution makes the Chairman of the Public Service Commission a member of the Police Service Commission, and the Public Service Commission had no Chairman. The Police Service Commission was therefore not duly constituted. Consultation with it up to 29 June 2022 on the acting Commissioner was void, and the invitation to consult on Mr Hicken could not proceed until the Commission was properly constituted. Its past acts were validated under the de facto doctrine. In a postscript she criticised the delays in constituting the commissions.
On 4 August Younge J refused an application for the eight suspended Opposition MPs to attend sittings of the National Assembly pending their challenge. On 10 August she refused an interim order blocking the suspension and fixed 1 November for oral argument.
Except where stated, these accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. The accounts of the Hicken and Commissions decisions are taken from the written judgments. Nothing here comments on the merits of matters still pending.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
