Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

The DPP's Power to Overrule Magistrates Struck Down, Guyana's ICJ Memorial and the Interim Town Clerk's Appointment

March 2022

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The CCJ held that the DPP's statutory power to direct a magistrate to commit an accused for trial after a discharge is unconstitutional. Guyana filed its Memorial on the merits in the border case against Venezuela. The High Court ruled on the interim Town Clerk's appointment and on the cancellation of a fuel import licence. Continuous registration resumed.

The National Registration (Residents) Order 2022 (Order No. 4, made 2 March) began a period of continuous registration on 7 March, with 31 October 2022 as the qualifying date. Registration was to be suspended temporarily on 29 May. The Order applies to everyone qualified to be an elector and to all other persons in Guyana who would be 14 or older by the qualifying date. People already on the Central Register may correct their particulars or transfer. Three National Industrial and Commercial Investments Limited (Transfer of Property) Orders (Nos. 6 to 8 of 2022) were published on 26 March, and Order No. 36 of 2021 on 12 March. Further Public Health Ordinance regulations (Regulations No. 8) were published on 14 March.

On 15 March the CCJ decided Bisram v DPP [2022] CCJ 7 (AJ) GY. A magistrate had discharged Mr Bisram at a preliminary inquiry into a murder charge. Acting under section 72 of the Criminal Law (Procedure) Act, the DPP directed the magistrate to reopen the inquiry and commit him for trial. In a judgment delivered by Saunders P, the Court held that section 72 is inconsistent with the separation of powers and the independence of the courts guaranteed by article 122A of the Constitution, which extends to magistrates. The savings clause in article 152 did not protect it. The DPP had not, in any event, followed the steps that section 72 required. The discharge was restored. Mr Bisram could not be made to answer the charge on the same evidence, although fresh evidence could found a new charge. Until Parliament acts, section 72 is to be read as allowing the DPP to place the depositions before a judge of the Supreme Court on an ex parte application. If the judge considers that the material justifies it, the judge may order that the discharged person be arrested and committed for trial.

On 8 March Guyana filed its Memorial on the merits at the International Court of Justice in its case against Venezuela over the validity of the 1899 Arbitral Award, within the time the Court had fixed. CARICOM reaffirmed its support the day before.

In Rock Hard Distribution Ltd v Trinidad and Tobago and the Caribbean Community [2022] CCJ 2 (OJ) (2 March), importers of Turkish cement challenged the decision of the Council for Trade and Economic Development (COTED) allowing Trinidad and Tobago to suspend the 5 per cent common external tariff on other hydraulic cement and charge 50 per cent for 2021. The Court held that it has jurisdiction to decide whether, and how far, WTO law forms part of Community law. It concluded, however, that the Community is not a WTO member and is not bound by WTO law when it sets tariff rates, so the WTO bound rate did not limit COTED's power. The claim was dismissed.

In Sandy Lane Hotel Co Ltd v Cato [2022] CCJ 8 (AJ) BB (24 March) the CCJ upheld findings that three hotel employees dismissed in 2012 after a "mystery shopper" report had been wrongfully dismissed. The company had not followed the disciplinary process incorporated into their contracts.

From the Guyana Courts

On 17 March Barlow J decided a challenge by the Town Clerk of Georgetown to the appointment of an interim Town Clerk by the Local Government Commission. He held that the decision of 27 July 2021, taken by the Commission's Chair and Deputy Chair alone, was outside their authority, void and incapable of ratification. The Commission's own vote of 23 August 2021 was, however, a fresh and valid decision, and the appointment runs from that date. The other grounds were dismissed and no order was made as to costs.

In a judgment dated 22 March, Holder J held that the Chief Executive Officer of the Guyana Energy Agency had no power to cancel Atlantic Fuels Inc's import and wholesale licence on the basis that it had submitted a false invoice. Regulation 70 of the Petroleum and Petroleum Products Regulations 2014 creates a summary offence, and only a court can decide whether it was committed. The cancellation was ultra vires. Certiorari quashed it and mandamus was granted to reinstate the licence, with costs.

On 9 March Gino Persaud J refused the Attorney General's application to bring an end to the challenge to the President's suspension of the members of the former Police Service Commission. The Commission had ceased to exist while the case was pending. The judge allowed the former Chairman, Paul Slowe, to be substituted as applicant. Earlier in the month Harnanan J dismissed the Guyana Civil Servants and General Workers Union's challenge to the Trade Union Recognition and Certification Board's refusal to decertify the union recognised for certain staff of the Guyana Geology and Mines Commission. The challenging union had won the poll but obtained 31.73 per cent support across the bargaining unit. The judge held that the 40 per cent threshold in the proviso to section 21 of the Trade Union Recognition Act applies to the whole section.

Except where stated, these accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. The accounts of the Town Clerk and Atlantic Fuels decisions are taken from the written judgments. Nothing here comments on the merits of matters still pending.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.