The High Court held that exempting only the Chancellor and the Chief Justice from income tax discriminated against other judges, Bills were published requiring personal appearance and photo identification for powers of attorney, constitutional office holders and MPs received 7 per cent increases, and the CCJ held that an arm's length auction price is the best evidence of value for stamp duty.
On 22 November two Bills were published to deal with fraud by forged or improperly executed powers of attorney. They were republished on 10 December. The Powers of Attorney (Amendment) Bill 2021 (Bill No. 15) would insert a new section 2A setting procedures for a notary public, magistrate or justice of the peace who prepares a power of attorney. The donor and the donee would have to appear personally together, and each would provide two photographic identification documents. A witness statement would be required where the power is executed outside Guyana. The Deeds Registry (Amendment) Bill 2021 (Bill No. 16) would make it an offence to register, file or record a power of attorney without the attached copies of the identification documents and, where required, the witness statement.
The problem the Bills address was before the CCJ in February, in Todd v Price. There, land sold under a forged power of attorney was lost to its owner because the purchaser's transport was protected.
On 30 November two Orders increased, with effect from 1 January 2021, by 7 per cent the salaries of the holders of constitutional offices (Constitutional Offices (Remuneration of Holders) Order 2021, Order No. 29) and of Ministers, Members of the National Assembly and special office holders (Order No. 30). On 8 November a NICIL (Transfer of Property) Order (Order No. 37) provided for a transfer of property by NICIL to Cardiology Services Inc. On 17 November the Prospecting Licence (Exemption) Order 2021 (Order No. 31) exempted Aurous Guyana Inc. from the application procedures for a prospecting licence over a block in the Rupununi Mining District. Further exemption Orders (Nos. 26 to 28) and Mining (Special) Regulations No. 13 followed. Regulations No. 10 of 2021, the Public Health Ordinance (COVID-19) Emergency Measures, were published on 30 November.
At the CCJ, in G A Roe & Sons Ltd v Commissioner of Stamps [2021] CCJ 12 (AJ) BZ (17 November), a company bought land from a bank at public auction for $150,000 and paid stamp duty on that price. The Commissioner assessed the value at $335,000 on a valuer's report, treating the auction as a forced sale. Saunders PCCJ, for the Court, held that the Commissioner had not followed the procedure in section 28 of the Stamp Duties Act for calling for evidence, and had misdirected herself in treating the price as meaningless. "Far from being meaningless, the actual consideration produced by an arm's length transparent sale between a willing buyer and a willing seller is the best evidence of the value of land." Burgess JCCJ, concurring, held that even a broadly worded discretion is bounded by the policy and objects of the Act. The appeal was allowed.
From the Guyana Courts
On 12 November Corbin-Lincoln J was reported to have declared section 13(a) of the Income Tax Act, as amended in 2004, unconstitutional, void and of no effect, in so far as it exempted the emoluments of the Chancellor and the Chief Justice, but not those of other judges, from income tax. The claim was brought in 2015 by a judge who has since retired, William Ramlal. The State had not shown that the difference in treatment had a legitimate aim. The two offices' hierarchy and administrative duties were already reflected in their pay. The provision therefore breached the guarantee of equality in article 149D. He was awarded $2.5 million, but failed in his claim to a declaration about the level of his pension.
On 19 November Navindra Singh J awarded a teacher $5 million, including aggravated damages, for Facebook posts about him that were held to be defamatory. The judge held that the words bore their ordinary meaning of serious criminal conduct. Fair comment failed because the posts made imputations of fact, and the defendant "failed to produce one iota of evidence" to justify them. Publication on social media and the persistence with a plea of justification aggravated the damages. The judge compared the award with recent awards, including those against Kaieteur News.
Except where stated, these accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. The account of the libel award to the teacher is taken from the written judgment. Nothing here comments on the merits of any appeal.
Also this month
Marcus Bisram's appeal against the Court of Appeal's May decision on his committal was listed for hearing at the CCJ on 11 November.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
