The High Court refused unions an interim injunction against the COVID-19 vaccination requirements, the Chief Justice awarded a Jamaican national $3.1 million for unlawful detention and inhumane lockup conditions, and the twenty-second Emergency Measures limited several businesses to vaccinated staff and patrons.
The twenty-second COVID-19 Emergency Measures, published on 4 September, define "vaccinated" as having received at least one dose of a listed vaccine or any other approved by the Minister of Health. They make the operators of gyms and fitness centres, casinos, betting shops and cinemas responsible for ensuring that only vaccinated persons, staff and patrons alike, are on their premises. Those persons must carry official identification and their vaccination card and produce them on request. The twenty-third set followed on 30 September.
The Minister made two Prospecting Permit Medium Scale (PPMS) Exemption Orders on 11 September (Orders Nos. 19 and 20). Further Orders in the series followed in October, November and December. On 13 September Order No. 21 revoked the acquisition order for land for access roads to the new Demerara River crossing. On 21 September an Order was made under the Land Registry Act (Order No. 36). In October it was followed by further commencement Orders for section 43 of that Act.
The CCJ delivered no judgments in September.
From the Guyana Courts
On 17 September Corbin-Lincoln J refused the Guyana Teachers' Union, the Guyana Public Service Union and the Guyana Trades Union Congress an interim injunction against the vaccination requirements. The unions had asked the court to restrain the State from applying section 17 of the twentieth Measures, which governed access to public buildings by unvaccinated persons including public servants, and to order the State to bear the cost of PCR testing. According to the reports, the judge found serious issues to be tried as to whether the President acted outside the powers conferred by section 21 of the Public Health Ordinance, including whether COVID-19 is a disease to which that section extends. But the State has a duty to take steps to avert the spread of disease. Granting the injunction would not be in the interest of "stability of the public" while the lawfulness of the measures remained undecided, and the balance of convenience was against it. The substantive claim was to be heard later, and no order was made as to costs.
On 29 September the Chief Justice (ag) awarded Sandra Russell, a Jamaican national, $3.1 million against the State. After serving a sentence for a drugs offence in 2018, she was held for five months at the East La Penitence police station awaiting deportation, in conditions the court was reported to have found inhumane. The court awarded $500,000 for each month of unlawful detention and $75,000 for each of the eight months she spent in police lockups, holding that the conditions of detention were relevant whether or not the detention itself was lawful. The awards were "largely compensatory" and far below the sums claimed. The Chief Justice also directed that the cost of Ms Russell's return to Jamaica, unless she could meet it herself, be deducted from the award.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of the pending vaccination claim.
Also this month
The unions' substantive claim also asks the court to declare that the President's direction of 16 March 2020 under the Public Health Ordinance was an improper delegation of power. The hearing is awaited.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
