The Government published seven Bills to amend the criminal, family and evidence laws, the CCJ permanently stayed a Belizean sentence because the appeal took nine years and held that a buyer's year of missed instalments justified ending a sale of land in Berbice, and the Chief Justice upheld the Police Service Commission's practice of passing over officers with disciplinary matters pending.
On 4 and 7 June seven Bills were published. They would amend the Summary Jurisdiction (Offences) Act (Bill No. 6), the Civil Law of Guyana Act (No. 7), the Police Act (No. 8), the Firearms Act (No. 9), the Registration of Births and Deaths Act (No. 10), the Evidence Act (No. 11) and the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (Control) Act (No. 12). They were passed later in the year, and their contents are described in the August and December dockets as enacted. On 7 June the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (Control) (Amendment of Second Schedule) Order 2021 (Order No. 8) amended the schedule of controlled substances.
The Supplementary Appropriation (No. 1 for 2021) Act 2021 (Act No. 7) was published on 16 June after the Bill appeared on 10 June. On 22 June the Immigration (Revocation) Order 2021 (Order No. 9), made by the President, revoked the Immigration Order 2019 (No. 3 of 2019). The same day, the Pesticides and Toxic Chemicals Control (Prohibited Pesticides) (Amendment) Order 2021 (Order No. 10) amended the list of prohibited pesticides. Two National Industrial and Commercial Investments Limited (Transfer of Property) Orders (Nos. 15 and 16) were published on 30 June. A Proclamation concerning the Civil Defence Commission was published on 10 June.
At the CCJ, Marin v The Queen [2021] CCJ 6 (AJ) BZ (23 June) is an important decision on remedies for delay. Nine years passed between the appellant's conviction for kidnapping and robbery and the decision of his appeal. The State admitted that this breached his right to a hearing within a reasonable time, but the Court of Appeal of Belize, finding the conviction otherwise sound, gave no remedy. Jamadar JCCJ held that an appellate court may grant constitutional relief for a breach that arises in the proceedings before it, without a separate originating application. Barrow JCCJ explained why a declaration and a permanent stay of further enforcement of the sentences were the right remedies. Anderson JCCJ agreed. The appeal was allowed. Article 144 of Guyana's Constitution protects the same right, so the reasoning will be persuasive for delays in the Court of Appeal here.
In Blairmont Rice Investment Inc v Kayman Sankar Investments Ltd [2021] CCJ 7 (AJ) GY (25 June), the purchaser of lands at Von Better, Berbice, under three 2006 agreements stopped paying the half-yearly instalments in 2010. The vendors treated the agreements as repudiated. The courts below found for the vendors. Burgess JCCJ, for the majority, held that the instalment clause was neither a condition nor a warranty but an innominate term. However, a full year's default, which exposed the vendors to the loss of their properties to their bank, deprived them of substantially the whole benefit of the contract, so they were entitled to end it. On a point raised for the first time at the CCJ, the majority held that a company struck off the register keeps its legal personality for the purpose of liabilities enforced against it, so it can be sued and can defend, although it cannot enforce claims of its own until restored. Saunders PCCJ dissented on that second point. The appeal was dismissed. Burgess JCCJ added that a search of the Companies Register should be made before litigation against a company begins.
On 4 June the CCJ also dismissed the appeals in the Aremu Road procurement case against the Guyana Geology and Mines Commission's award of a road contract. It gave its reasons in December.
From the Guyana Courts
On 28 June the Chief Justice (ag) dismissed an application by Senior Superintendent Calvin Brutus. She was reported to have held that the Police Service Commission acts lawfully when it does not promote officers with pending disciplinary matters, that promotion is neither a right nor a legitimate expectation, and that an officer is not entitled to be heard before being passed over. He had produced no evidence that the officers promoted ahead of him had matters pending. She called for comprehensive regulations on discipline and promotion and for disciplinary complaints to be decided within a reasonable time. Petitioners also filed their appeal against the dismissal of Petition 88 on 3 June.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Nothing here comments on the merits of the matters under appeal.
Also this month
The nineteenth COVID-19 Emergency Measures were published on 30 June.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
