Five months after polling day the Elections Commission declared the results on the basis of the recount and the first election petition was filed, the Chief Justice held that the Red House lease could not be revoked without cause, and the CCJ upheld the winding up of a deadlocked family company.
On 2 August the Guyana Elections Commission declared the results of the elections of 2 March on the basis of the recount conducted under Order No. 60 of 2020, and Mohamed Irfaan Ali was sworn in as President. The national top-up declaration published in the Official Gazette on 20 August records 460,352 valid votes, of which 233,336 were cast for the PPP/C and 217,920 for APNU+AFC, with 4,213 rejected ballots. The national seats were allocated 21 to the PPP/C, 18 to APNU+AFC and one to the joined list of ANUG, LJP and TNM. The declaration is expressed to be made “in accordance with Order 60 of 2020 and its statutory obligations”, the formula the Commission settled on after the decisions of July.
By a proclamation under article 69 published as an addendum on 28 August, the President appointed the Arthur Chung Conference Centre as the place for the first session of the Twelfth Parliament, beginning on 1 September, and allowed Members to participate remotely by electronic means. The proclamation recites that there had been “a prolonged and undue delay in the declaration” beyond the President’s control, so that no session could have been held within the time prescribed by article 69(1), and that the Parliament Chamber was unsafe for sittings because of COVID-19. The new Government’s first item of subsidiary legislation, the Delegation of Functions (Revocation) Order 2020 (Order No. 74 of 2020), made on 7 August under section 27 of the Interpretation and General Clauses Act, revoked the 2016 order delegating certain functions to the Commissioner of the Guyana Lands and Surveys Commission. The COVID-19 Emergency Measures were renewed by the eighth and ninth sets, published on 14 and 31 August.
On 31 August the first election petition was filed in the High Court by two electors, Claudette Thorne and Heston Bostwick, with the support of APNU+AFC. It asks the court to determine whether the elections were lawfully conducted and whether the result was affected by unlawful acts or omissions, and seeks an order that the results be declared on the basis of the Returning Officers’ declarations of March, or alternatively that the elections be voided.
On 28 August the Caribbean Court of Justice dismissed the appeal in Nabi v Sheermohamed [2020] CCJ 15 (AJ) GY and upheld the winding up of Nabi and Sons Ltd, a family construction company, under section 354(e) of the Companies Act, Cap. 89:01, on the ground that it was just and equitable. The judgment of Wit and Burgess JJCCJ holds that “refusal to meet on matters of business, continued quarreling, and such a state of animosity as precludes all reasonable hope of reconciliation and friendly cooperation” suffices for a just and equitable winding up, and that this was what “screams from every page of the record”. On the unclean hands argument, the Court held that the courts below should have considered only the petitioner’s conduct, not balanced it against the appellants’, but the argument failed on its merits. In a postscript, Wit JCCJ apologised for the nine months the judgment had taken, which he described as excessive by the Court’s own standards. The case is a useful reminder for family companies in Guyana that decades of deadlock can end in a winding up order even where no single act of oppression is proved.
From the Guyana Courts
On 14 August George CJ (Ag) ruled in favour of the Cheddi Jagan Research Centre Inc. in its claim against the Attorney General and the Lands and Surveys Commission, filed in December 2016 after the then President ordered the revocation of its 99-year lease of Red House. The court is reported to have held that the building had not been properly registered as a national monument under section 15 of the National Trust Act, that the lease could be revoked only for cause and no breach was shown, and that a 99-year lease creates property protected by the Constitution. It granted a permanent conservatory order restraining the removal of the centre’s items without compensation, declined to grant separate constitutional relief and awarded costs of $150,000.
On 18 August Sewnarine-Beharry J awarded the former Deputy Chief Election Officer, Vishnu Persaud, $4 million in damages for defamation against the Guyana Chronicle, its former editor-in-chief and an elections commissioner, over articles suggesting that he had misrepresented his qualifications. The judge treated the commissioner’s standing as aggravating the damage, and noted that the statements had been defended as true in spite of plain evidence to the contrary and that no retraction or apology had been published.
In a decision reported on 15 August the Court of Appeal, the Chancellor (Ag), Gregory JA and Reynolds J, substituted a conviction for manslaughter and a sentence of 18 years for the murder conviction and death sentence of Herman Ally, convicted in Berbice in 2012, with credit for the time he had spent in custody since 2006.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. The election petitions remained pending, and nothing here comments on their merits.
Also this month
On 14 August the Chief Magistrate dismissed the 19 fraud-related charges pending against the President over the sale of lands at Pradoville Two, on an application relying on the immunity in article 182 of the Constitution, which bars criminal proceedings from being continued against a sitting President in respect of things done in a private capacity. Private criminal charges of conspiracy to defraud and breach of trust laid against the Chief Election Officer were referred to the Director of Public Prosecutions for review, and further charges arising from the elections were laid against officers of the Elections Commission at the end of the month. Those prosecutions were at an early stage and nothing here comments on them.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
