The Caribbean Court of Justice set aside the Court of Appeal’s decision and the Chief Election Officer’s report that departed from the recount, the High Court and the Court of Appeal held that the recount must be the basis of the declaration, and a second cement tariff claim was settled in the CCJ’s Original Jurisdiction.
On 8 July the Caribbean Court of Justice delivered a joint judgment of all five judges in Ali and Jagdeo v David [2020] CCJ 10 (AJ) GY. The Court granted special leave, allowed the appeal from the Court of Appeal’s decision of 22 June, held that the decision was made without jurisdiction and was “invalid and of no effect”, and declared that the Chief Election Officer’s report of 23 June was similarly of no effect.
The threshold issue was jurisdiction. Section 4(3) of the Caribbean Court of Justice Act, Cap. 3:07, excludes appeals from decisions declared final by law, and article 177(4) of the Constitution makes final the Court of Appeal’s decisions on questions as to the validity of an election of a President. The CCJ accepted that a decision genuinely made under article 177(4) cannot be appealed, but held that, as Guyana’s final court, it had the jurisdiction and the duty to decide whether a decision truly fell within that provision, which it described as “a limited, circumscribed carve out” of its jurisdiction, to be read together with the High Court’s exclusive jurisdiction over the validity of elections under article 163. Since there is no separate presidential election in Guyana, and a presidential candidate is deemed elected only as a result of the election of the National Assembly, a question as to the validity of a President’s election could arise only after the Assembly had been elected and a President declared. Ms David’s application was premature, and the questions she raised belonged to the High Court on an election petition.
On the merits, the Court held that article 177(2)(b) “has always said what it meant and meant what it said”, and needed no interpretation. The concept of “valid votes” has a settled meaning in the electoral legislation: it refers to votes valid on their face, as determined in the transparent process prescribed by the Representation of the People Act, in which spoilt and rejected ballots are weeded out in the presence of candidates and counting agents. Questions about the integrity of a ballot or the way a vote was procured, beyond that process, must be pursued by petition after the results are declared. Unless and until an election court decides otherwise, votes counted as valid in the recount could not be declared invalid by any person or authority other than the High Court on an election petition. By inserting the word “valid”, the Court of Appeal had impliedly invited the Chief Election Officer to undertake a unilateral and unlawful validation exercise. The Court added that the Chairman had been right to note that the Elections Commission lacked the legislative authority and the machinery to determine such irregularities itself, and that “it is for GECOM to ensure that the election results are swiftly declared in accordance with the Laws of Guyana.”
The judgment is the most important decision of the Court in Guyana’s constitutional law since the no-confidence cases of 2019. It confirms that the CCJ will police the boundaries of finality clauses, that the validation of votes is the transparent process prescribed by statute, and that challenges to the quality of an election belong to the election court.
From the Guyana Courts
After the CCJ’s judgment the Chief Election Officer’s further report again did not use the recount figures, and a voter, Misenga Jones, applied to the High Court to restrain the Elections Commission from declaring the results on the basis of the recount. She contended that section 22 of the Election Laws (Amendment) Act, under which Order No. 60 of 2020 was made, unconstitutionally conferred law-making power on the Commission, and that the CCJ’s judgment had invalidated the recount. In a decision reported on 20 July, George CJ (Ag) dismissed the application. She held that an earlier decision of the Court of Appeal, that a challenge to section 22 was a matter for an election petition, was a definitive and considered finding rather than obiter, so that the principle of res judicata applied, and that questions as to the constitutionality of electoral laws are to be determined on an election petition under article 163.
On 30 July the Court of Appeal, Gregory and Persaud JJA and Sewnarine-Beharry J, unanimously affirmed her decision. The court held that the CCJ had not nullified the recount votes or Order No. 60, and that the Chief Election Officer, as a statutory officer employed by the Commission, is subject to its direction and control and must report on the basis of the recount. Sewnarine-Beharry J said that the direction to prepare the report in accordance with the recount was “a valid, lawful directive which the CEO is required to obey”. The constitutionality of section 22 and the validity of Order No. 60 and of the recount votes were left to an election petition. The declaration followed in August.
These accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record; no written judgment has been located. Questions about the conduct of the elections were later raised in election petitions, and nothing here comments on their merits.
Also this month
On 23 July the CCJ recorded, in Mootilal Ramhit and Sons Contracting Ltd v State of Trinidad and Tobago [2020] CCJ 3 (OJ), a compromise, reached in the light of its judgment in Rock Hard Cement, of a claim about the suspension of the common external tariff on cement; by consent it declared that Trinidad and Tobago had failed to ensure that the claimant was consulted before the suspension was applied for and approved. In reasons given on 16 July in Sinckler v Sinckler [2020] CCJ 11 (AJ) BB, the Court explained that no “twelve months’ rule of practice” bars the enforcement of arrears of maintenance in Barbados, where the requirement is to act within a reasonable time, and on 28 July it reduced the successful appellants’ costs to 80 per cent in Caye International Bank Ltd v Haugen [2020] CCJ 14 (AJ) BZ. Reasons were also given for refusing special leave in criminal applications from Barbados in Rambarran v The Queen [2020] CCJ 12 (AJ) BB and Alexander v The Queen [2020] CCJ 13 (AJ) BB, the second reaffirming that an appellant may not raise in the CCJ grounds that were not argued in the Court of Appeal.
The COVID-19 Emergency Measures were renewed, with the fifth, sixth and seventh sets published on 2, 16 and 30 July, and further Supreme Court practice directions were gazetted on 3 and 8 July.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
