The Supreme Court issued its directions for remote hearings, the Court of Appeal held by a majority that only “valid votes” could determine the presidency, the Chief Election Officer submitted a report excluding more than 100,000 recounted ballots, and the Caribbean Court of Justice ruled on the suspension of the common external tariff on cement.
On 22 June the Chancellor (Ag) issued the Supreme Court of Judicature Practice Directions No. 2 of 2020, the Remote Hearings Directions 2020. The Second COVID-19 Emergency Directions, published on 3 June, had continued the suspension of in-person hearings from 25 May for a further month. The new Directions recognised that the courts would continue to sit remotely until the Chancellor directed otherwise, and declared that remote hearings “are real hearings”, to be conducted on the same principles as face-to-face hearings. A “court” was defined as any place, whether or not a courthouse, where a judicial officer elects to sit remotely, and the platforms the courts might use were listed as Skype, Microsoft Teams, Zoom Business, WhatsApp and teleconferencing. A court might direct a remote hearing on its own motion or on application, choosing between video and telephone as best served the interests of justice, and attorneys were advised to upgrade their equipment and to acquire scanning facilities. The Directions placed on a formal footing a practice that had grown up of necessity since March, and many of its features survived the pandemic.
The recount under Order No. 60 of 2020 concluded in early June, and in mid-June the Chairman of the Elections Commission directed the Chief Election Officer to prepare his report under section 96 of the Representation of the People Act on the basis of the recount figures. That direction provoked the litigation described below, and a report by the Chief Election Officer on 23 June that, relying on the Court of Appeal’s decision, excluded from the count more than 100,000 ballots that had been counted and certified during the recount. The Caribbean Court of Justice’s decision on that report is discussed in the July docket.
On 10 June the Court gave judgment in its Original Jurisdiction in Rock Hard Cement Ltd v State of Barbados [2020] CCJ 2 (OJ), with Arawak Cement Company Ltd intervening. In June 2019 the Council for Trade and Economic Development (COTED) had approved Barbados’ application to suspend the common external tariff of 5 per cent on “other hydraulic cement” and to replace it with a tariff of 35 per cent for two years. Rock Hard, which imports cement from Turkey, had not been consulted. The Court refused to annul the decision. A legitimate expectation enforceable in the Original Jurisdiction must arise from representations by the Community, not by a Member State, and none had been made by COTED; nor was the decision arbitrary or irrational, falling as it did within a category of decisions in which COTED has a broad discretion. But the Court declared that both Barbados and the Community had failed in their duty to consult an affected importer before the application was made and approved. The decision clarifies that private parties have procedural rights in the process for suspending the common external tariff, even where the outcome is lawful, and it led within weeks to a settlement in a parallel claim from Trinidad and Tobago, noted in the July docket.
From the Guyana Courts
On 22 June the Court of Appeal, by a majority, decided in favour of Eslyn David, an elector, on her application for an interpretation of article 177(2)(b) of the Constitution, under which the presidential candidate on the list for which “more votes are cast” is deemed elected. The Chancellor (Ag), Cummings-Edwards, and Gregory JA held that the Court had jurisdiction under article 177(4), which gives the Court of Appeal exclusive and final jurisdiction to determine questions as to the validity of an election of a President, and that the words must be read as “more valid votes”. Persaud JA dissented. He held that the Court lacked jurisdiction, since Parliament had made no provision giving effect to article 177(4) and no genuine question as to the validity of a presidential election arose, that the application was premature since no President had been declared, and that article 163 gives the High Court exclusive jurisdiction over the validity of elections. The Court stayed its judgment for three days, but the Chief Election Officer submitted his report the next day. On 23 June Mohamed Irfaan Ali, the PPP/C’s presidential candidate, and Bharrat Jagdeo, the Leader of the Opposition, applied to the Caribbean Court of Justice for special leave to appeal.
On 2 June Morris-Ramlall J quashed the committal of Marcus Bisram for trial for murder, which a magistrate had made on the direction of the Director of Public Prosecutions after she had discharged him at the close of the preliminary inquiry, and ordered his release. The judge held that there was insufficient evidence to justify the committal. The Director appealed. On 11 June George CJ (Ag) permitted the withdrawal of contempt proceedings against the Returning Officer for Region Four and members of the Elections Commission, brought by the applicant in the March case, observing that the evidence in support was “very, very deficient”.
The account of the Court of Appeal’s decision is taken from the Caribbean Court of Justice’s summary of it; the other accounts are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record. The Bisram appeal and the elections litigation then remained before the courts, and nothing here comments on their merits.
Also this month
On 30 June, in Belize International Services Ltd v Attorney General of Belize [2020] CCJ 9 (AJ) BZ, the CCJ held that the Government of Belize had breached its agreement with the manager of two international registries and could not rely on the illegality of the payment structure, which did not comply with the constitutional requirement that public monies be paid into the Consolidated Revenue Fund, to defeat the claim. The case was remitted for the assessment of damages. The judgment is significant wherever a State seeks to escape a commercial contract by pointing to its own failure to comply with public finance law.
The Ministry of Education also published, on 2 June, special COVID-19 measures for the administration of national examinations.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
