Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

The Recount Order, Totality in Sentencing and the First Appeal on Unfair Dismissal

May 2020

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The Elections Commission gazetted the order governing the national recount, the Caribbean Court of Justice reduced a cumulative 37-year sentence imposed in Guyana for sexual offences against a child, and it gave its first ruling on the Barbados Employment Rights Act.

On 4 May the Guyana Elections Commission published Order No. 60 of 2020, made under article 162 of the Constitution and section 22 of the Election Laws (Amendment) Act, No. 15 of 2000, which empowers the Commission to issue orders removing difficulties in the application of the Representation of the People Act. The Order recited that declarations had been made under section 84(1) of that Act, that requests for recounts had been rejected, aborted or held in abeyance, that the President, the Leader of the Opposition and all contesting parties had agreed to a CARICOM proposal for a total recount, and that the Commission had decided on 3 April to recount all ballots cast in every district. Reflecting the Court of Appeal’s ruling in April, it stated that the recount would be undertaken, executed and supervised by the Commission, and scrutinised by a CARICOM team.

The Order set out the Commission’s role, including the supervision of the Secretariat, the resolution of unresolved issues and the determination and declaration of the final results. The recount, conducted by Commission employees under the direct supervision of the Chief Election Officer at the Arthur Chung Conference Centre, began on 6 May. Each ballot box was to be examined to see that its seals were intact, its contents recorded on a ballot box checklist, and any further matter recorded on an observations report signed by the workstation supervisor and the party representatives. The result of each box was recorded on a Statement of Recount, and the statements were tabulated in a matrix at a central tabulation centre in the presence of the parties, the CARICOM team and the observers, with images and audio of the workstations broadcast live. An addendum of 29 May fixed 13 June as the date by which the recount was to conclude, increased the workstations to twelve, and provided that the Commission, having deliberated on the Chief Election Officer’s report of the recount, would decide whether to direct him to use the recount data as the basis of his report under section 96 of the Representation of the People Act, and would declare the results of “the final credible count” within three days. Those provisions would become the battleground of the litigation in June and July.

On 14 May the Caribbean Court of Justice delivered judgment in Pompey v Director of Public Prosecutions [2020] CCJ 7 (AJ) GY. The appellant had been convicted under the Sexual Offences Act 2010 of one count of sexual assault and two of rape of a fourteen-year-old girl, and sentenced to 5, 15 and 17 years, to run consecutively, a total of 37 years. All seven judges agreed that the cumulative sentence was excessive. Delivering the majority judgment, the President, Saunders PCCJ, explained that the totality principle is akin to proportionality: where a judge sentences for several offences, the overall sentence must reflect all the offending behaviour, but must be neither too harsh nor too lenient. Consecutive sentences may be appropriate for offences committed against the same person on different dates, but the judge must then have regard to totality, and here no such regard had been paid. The majority left the sentence of 17 years for the second rape undisturbed and ordered the other two sentences to run concurrently with it. Wit and Anderson JJCCJ, dissenting in part, would have reduced the overall sentence to nine years. Rajnauth-Lee JCCJ, concurring, drew attention to the alarming prevalence of sexual offences in Guyana. The President added that the practice of passing sentence immediately after the verdict should generally be avoided where a long term of imprisonment is likely, in favour of a separate sentencing hearing at which mitigating and aggravating factors, including psychological assessments, can properly be considered.

From the Guyana Courts

No significant decision of the High Court or the Court of Appeal in May has been located. With the courts working under the COVID-19 practice directions, the reported court business of the month was largely in the magistrates’ courts, where persons were charged and fined for breaches of the curfew and of the requirement to wear face masks in public.

This account is taken from press reports; nothing here comments on the merits of any individual case.

Also this month

On 7 May the CCJ delivered judgment in Chefette Restaurants Ltd v Harris [2020] CCJ 6 (AJ) BB, its first appeal under the Barbados Employment Rights Act 2012. An assistant manager had been dismissed after a disputed cheque was deposited at his branch. The Court upheld the finding of unfair dismissal, holding that where the reason for dismissal relates to the employee’s conduct or capability the employer must comply with the statutory disciplinary procedures, and that the appellate court’s role in reviewing findings of fact by the Employment Rights Tribunal is very limited. But it allowed the appeal on compensation: the basic award, equivalent to severance pay, compensates both for past service and for future loss of wages, so that the Tribunal had erred in making a separate award for lost wages, and the award was reduced to the basic award of $31,274.78. The judgment repays study in Guyana, where the Termination of Employment and Severance Pay Act raises similar questions.

On 27 May, in Bay Trust Corporate Services Ltd v Longsworth [2020] CCJ 8 (AJ) BZ, the Court affirmed a finding of constructive dismissal of a managing director whose functions had been taken over by the company’s majority shareholder and chairman, whose acts were attributed to the company.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.