Guyana held its General and Regional Elections, the President declared COVID-19 an infectious disease and the courts moved to emergency practice, the Caribbean Court of Justice gave its first advisory opinion, and the High Court set aside the Region Four declaration.
The General and Regional Elections were held on 2 March 2020. Their aftermath, and the litigation it produced, are recorded in the section on the Guyana courts below and will run through the dockets for the rest of the year.
On 16 March, days after Guyana confirmed its first imported case, the Extraordinary Gazette published a Direction by the President under the Public Health Ordinance, Cap. 145. The Direction recited the constitutional bases for restricting liberty and movement to prevent the spread of infectious disease, in articles 139(1)(g) and 148(3)(b), and relied on the second proviso to section 21(1) of the Ordinance, which allows the President to exercise the powers of the Central Board of Health where immediate action is needed and a meeting of the Board is not practicable. The President declared COVID-19 an infectious disease and directed the Minister of Public Health to take measures to isolate persons suffering from or exposed to the disease, to provide treatment, to disinfect or destroy infected property, to restrict the movement of persons and conveyances to and from infected areas, and to take any other measures considered necessary. This Direction is the legal foundation of the emergency measures that followed from April onwards. Its reliance on a colonial-era Ordinance, rather than on emergency legislation passed for the purpose, was to be tested in the months ahead.
On 23 March the Chancellor (Ag), with the concurrence of the Chief Justice (Ag), issued the Supreme Court of Judicature Practice Directions No. 1 of 2020, the COVID-19 Emergency Directions 2020, applying to the Supreme Court and the Magistrates’ Courts for an initial period of one month. Chamber matters and Full Bench sittings of the Court of Appeal were suspended except for urgent applications and appeals; urgent applications before a judge in chambers were to be heard by telephone or electronic means as far as possible; and in-person hearings were to observe social distancing. The Directions began a rapid shift to remote hearings that would outlast the emergency.
On 4 March the Caribbean Court of Justice refused special leave in Persaud v Nizamudin [2020] CCJ 4 (AJ) GY. Navindra Singh J had ordered the sale of a property held jointly under a transfer of lease and an equal division of the proceeds, on a fixed date application under the Immovable Property (Sale of Interests) Act. The Court of Appeal struck out the appeal on the ground that the proceeding was a summary one, so that the appeal lay to the Full Court. The CCJ agreed: “summary proceedings” included cases capable of quick resolution without the full processes of a trial, and the fixed date application in this case was such a proceeding. The decision is important for practitioners under the Civil Procedure Rules 2016, since an appeal filed in the wrong court may be lost altogether.
On 18 March the Court delivered its first advisory opinion under the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas, Re Request for an Advisory Opinion [2020] CCJ 1 (OJ) AO, at the request of the Conference of Heads of Government. The Conference had extended the categories of skilled CARICOM nationals entitled to free movement to agricultural workers and security guards, and had allowed Antigua and Barbuda and St Kitts and Nevis to opt out for five years. The Court advised that freedom of movement is a fundamental objective of the Community, but that the opt-outs, being temporary, limited to two categories and granted to less developed countries, did not prejudice that objective and were lawful under article 27(4). It also advised that opt-outs are non-reciprocal, so that agricultural workers and security guards from the two opting-out States remained entitled to the benefit of the decision in other Member States.
From the Guyana Courts
On 11 March George CJ (Ag) held, in Holladar v Returning Officer, Electoral District No. 4, that the Returning Officer for Demerara-Mahaica had not complied with section 84(1) of the Representation of the People Act in tabulating the statements of poll before declaring the district’s results on 5 March. On 8 March she had rejected the argument that the matter could only be raised by an election petition. In her written judgment she found that a significant part of the addition of votes had been done in the absence of the persons entitled to be present, that the presumption of regularity could not apply, and that the non-compliance vitiated the declaration. The declaration was set aside, and the Returning Officer was directed to resume a compliant tabulation. A further declaration made on 13 March led to the agreement, brokered by CARICOM, for a national recount.
On 11 March Harnanan J quashed the respite granted by the President under article 188(1)(b) of the Constitution to the Minister of Finance, who had been committed for 21 days for contempt for failing to pay a judgment of about US$2.2 million in favour of the contractor DIPCON. As reported, the judge held that the respite was unlawful and arbitrary, being an interference by the executive in a matter the courts had decided. The Attorney General appealed. The judgment debt itself had been paid in December 2019.
On 27 March Holder J held that the High Court had jurisdiction to hear the application by Ulita Moore for judicial review of the decision to have a CARICOM team oversee the recount; interim injunctions he had earlier granted were halting the recount. On 31 March the Full Court, George CJ (Ag) and Harnanan J, discharged the injunctions and dismissed the application, holding that the challenge could only be brought by an election petition. The appeal to the Court of Appeal is discussed in the April docket.
The Holladar account is taken from a copy of the written judgment; the others are taken from press reports and have not been verified against the court record. The respite appeal and the elections litigation then remained before the courts, and nothing here comments on their merits.
Also this month
On 2 March the CCJ dismissed the appeal in Ellis v The Queen [2020] CCJ 3 (AJ) BB, a bail appeal that had become academic when the appellant was acquitted and released.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
