The President dissolved Parliament and the Regional Democratic Councils with effect from 30 December, ahead of the elections on 2 March 2020. The CCJ lifted a partial stay of execution and corrected the Court of Appeal's arithmetic. The High Court held that the GRA could not garnish a judgment sum owed to a contractor, and the Court of Appeal set out how sentencing judges should give reasons.
By a proclamation made on 27 December under articles 61 and 70(2) of the Constitution (Seal No. 189 of 2019), the President dissolved the Eleventh Parliament with effect from 30 December 2019. The proclamation appointed 2 March 2020 for the election of members of the National Assembly, "the issue and publication of any other Proclamation pursuant to the Constitution in this regard notwithstanding". A second proclamation (Seal No. 190), made under article 73(2), dissolved the ten Regional Democratic Councils on the same date and appointed the same day for their elections. The Constitutional Offices (Remuneration of Holders) Order 2019 (Order No. 92), made on 2 December and gazetted on 3 December, increased the salaries of holders of constitutional offices with effect from 1 January 2019, by percentages graduated by salary band: salaries up to $64,220 were raised to a new minimum of $70,000, and the increases then ran from 9 per cent through 8.5 per cent to 3 per cent at $1,000,000 and above.
In Shantidai v Barama Co Ltd [2019] CCJ 21 (AJ), decided on 9 December and reported at [2019] GLR 348, the applicant's son had been killed when his fishing boat sank after being hit by a pontoon towed by the respondent's barge. A single judge of the Court of Appeal had stayed execution of the High Court judgment pending appeal, save for $2,000,000, and the Full Bench had upheld the stay. The CCJ granted special leave, treated the application as the appeal, and set the partial stay aside. It noted that there was no evidence that the applicant would be unable to repay if the appeal succeeded. The challenges to the principles on which damages were assessed remained for the Court of Appeal. Using the power in Part 3, article XXV, section 6 of the CCJ Agreement, however, the CCJ corrected calculation errors, replacing an award of $12,450,000 with $6,850,000. The original interest rates were to apply to the substituted award, and the $2,000,000 already paid was to be deducted.
From the Guyana Courts
In Dipcon Engineering Services Ltd v Guyana Revenue Authority [2019] GLR 354 (16 December), Harnanan J considered the GRA's attempt to garnish, for unpaid taxes, a 2015 judgment of US$2,228,400 against the State in the contractor's favour. The judge declared that the contractor was not a person liable to make a payment of tax within section 102 of the Income Tax Act when the Commissioner General's letter of 8 July 2019 was issued. In purporting to garnish the judgment sum the Commissioner General had erred in law and exceeded his jurisdiction. The determination and the letters were set aside.
In Nero v The State [2019] GLR 363 (16 December), the Court of Appeal reduced a 30-year sentence for the rape of a child to 18 years. The sentencing judge had not identified the relevant factors, stated the effect of the aggravating and mitigating circumstances, or explained the discount for the guilty plea. As a general rule, full credit should be given for time spent on remand, and clear reasons should be given if little or no reduction is made. The protection of children remained an aggravating consideration that the sentence had to reflect.
The accounts of Shantidai, Dipcon and Nero are taken from the reports at [2019] GLR 348, 354 and 363.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
