By proclamation the President appointed 2 March 2020 for the national and regional elections. The CCJ refused a former soldier special leave to appeal his manslaughter conviction. The High Court dismissed a distribution claim and awarded the defendants damages for an injunction wrongly obtained.
On 1 October the President issued two proclamations. The first (Seal No. 164 of 2019), made under article 61 of the Constitution, appointed 2 March 2020 as the day for the election of members of the National Assembly under article 60(2). The second (Seal No. 165 of 2019), made under article 73(2), appointed the same day for elections to the Regional Democratic Councils. On 5 October the Guyana Defence Force (Pensions and Gratuities) (Amendment) Regulations 2019 (Regulations No. 6) and the Prospecting Permit Medium Scale (PPMS) Exemption Order 2019 (Order No. 71) were gazetted.
In Fraser v The State [2019] CCJ 17 (AJ), decided on 25 October and reported at [2019] GLR 328, the CCJ refused special leave to a former soldier convicted in 2007 of gross negligence manslaughter. His appeal was not heard until about ten years later. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal against conviction but held that the delay breached his right under article 144(1) to a hearing within a reasonable time, and it stayed any further imprisonment. The CCJ restated the test for special leave in criminal cases. The applicant must show a realistic possibility that a serious miscarriage of justice may have occurred, or a point of law of general importance that should be determined lest a questionable precedent remain. The standard is arguability, and the applicant must identify specific evidence or passages in the summing-up. The Court of Appeal had made no reviewable error in hearing the delay point and the substantive appeal together, and no realistic possibility of a serious miscarriage of justice arose.
From the Guyana Courts
In Parmanand v Lasco Manufacturing Ltd [2019] GLR 324 (14 October), Singh PJ dismissed a claim by a self-described sole agent and distributor of a manufacturer's iCool juices and waters. The claimant had placed no orders with the manufacturer after the first half of 2016, and there was no valid contract between them when the manufacturer supplied another distributor. The claim that the other defendants induced a breach of contract failed. The claimant had obtained an injunction in October 2017. He was ordered to pay $500,000 to each defendant as damages for the loss caused by it, together with costs. The costs award included $1,500,000 to a defendant whose witness had travelled from Jamaica.
The accounts of Fraser and Parmanand are taken from the reports at [2019] GLR 328 and 324.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
