Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

The Court of Appeal Requires Thirty-Four Votes, the CCJ Declines to Intervene for Bisram and Bills of Sale Considered by the Full Court

March 2019

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

A majority of the Court of Appeal held that the no-confidence motion was not validly passed, and the court rejected the dual-citizenship challenge to the decisive vote. The CCJ refused special leave in the Bisram matter. The Full Court explained when the time to renew a bill of sale can be extended. Commencement orders were made for deposit insurance and the national payments system.

The Deposit Insurance Act 2018 (Commencement) Order 2019 (Order No. 13), made on 27 March and gazetted on 28 March, brought the Act into operation on 2 April 2019. Parts V to IX were to come into force on 3 April. The National Payments System Act 2018 (Commencement) Order 2019 (Order No. 5), gazetted on 27 March, appointed 3 June 2019 for that Act.

In Inderjali v Director of Public Prosecutions [2019] CCJ 4 (AJ), decided on 11 March and reported at [2019] GLR 76, the applicant's son was charged in Guyana with murder but had returned to the United States, where extradition proceedings were under way. In his absence the High Court refused an application to restrain the DPP, and the Court of Appeal refused an expedited hearing. The CCJ refused special leave. Once a charge had properly been laid, Guyanese law did not allow an accused to remain abroad and have his committal proceedings attended on his behalf. The alleged recantation by a witness had not occurred in relation to him, because the preliminary inquiry against him had not begun, and it did not necessarily mean the case would collapse. The Court recommended measures to expedite the preliminary inquiry.

From the Guyana Courts

On 22 March the Court of Appeal decided the Attorney General's appeals in Attorney General v Ram and Leader of the Opposition [2019] GLR 81. The report sets out the judgment of Cummings-Edwards C (ag). She held that, for an absolute majority in a 65-member Assembly, one must be added after rounding up, so that 34 votes were required. The motion was therefore not validly passed, and she would allow the appeal. The court divided two to one: Gregory JA agreed in the result and Persaud JA dissented.

In Reid v Scotland, Attorney General and Harmon [2019] GLR 106, decided the same day, the court considered the dual citizenship of the member whose vote had carried the motion. Under article 155(1)(a), a person under an acknowledgment of allegiance to a foreign state "by his or her own act" does not qualify for election. Gregory JA held that declarations sought nearly four years after the 2015 results were rightly refused, because they fell foul of article 163 and the National Assembly (Validity of Elections) Act. The Speaker had not acted unlawfully in accepting the vote, and the vote did not end in a tie. Gregory JA would affirm the Chief Justice (ag) except on her finding that the High Court lacked jurisdiction over some of the claims, and so would allow the appeal in part; Persaud JA would have dismissed it. The report does not include a judgment of the Chancellor (ag) or the court's formal order. The CCJ later recorded that the Court of Appeal agreed with the Chief Justice (ag) that the challenge was barred by the National Assembly (Validity of Elections) Act and that the vote was valid under article 165(2).

In Trans Pacific Motor Spares and Auto Sales Inc v Deeds and Commercial Registries Authority [2019] GLR 131 (29 March), the Full Court dismissed appeals about bills of sale over motor vehicles that had lapsed under section 9(1) of the Bills of Sale Act for want of renewal. The court may extend the time for renewal if the omission was accidental or inadvertent. No renewal was needed for vehicles seized while their bills of sale were valid: the holder could sell them and transfer registration under the Motor Vehicles and Road Traffic Act. A vehicle seized after its bill of sale had expired was different. Extending time in that case would ratify a void transaction.

The accounts of Attorney General v Ram, Reid and Trans Pacific are taken from the reports at [2019] GLR 81, 106 and 131. The division of the Court of Appeal in Attorney General v Ram, and its findings on the dual-citizenship challenge, are taken from the CCJ's later judgment at [2019] GLR 184. An appeal to the CCJ followed, and nothing here comments on its merits.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.