The Court of Appeal unanimously affirmed the dismissal of the challenge to the appointment of the GECOM Chairman. The Elections Commission applied the disciplined forces voting rules to the local government elections. The CCJ awarded vindicatory damages for an excessive search in Belize.
By Order No. 36, made and gazetted on 19 October, the Guyana Elections Commission directed under section 65H of the Representation of the People Act that Part VIIB of that Act would govern voting by members of the Guyana Defence Force, the Guyana Police Force and the Guyana Prison Service in the local authorities elections.
On 17 October, in Titan International Securities Inc v Attorney General of Belize [2018] CCJ 28 (AJ), the CCJ considered a search of a company's offices under Belize's Mutual Legal Assistance and International Co-operation Act, made at the request of the United States. The search power in section 18 of that Act was a justifiable and proportionate limit on the constitutional protections against search of property and against arbitrary interference with privacy. The search itself was excessive. No copy of the warrant or inventory was left, irrelevant material was taken and the company's attorney was refused entry. The company had not proved that the search caused the loss of its business, since its regulatory licence had been suspended separately and it had not sought a review. The Court allowed the appeal in part and awarded BZD$100,000 in vindicatory damages for breach of the right to privacy.
From the Guyana Courts
On 18 October the Court of Appeal unanimously dismissed the appeal against the High Court's decision in Mustapha v Attorney General (reported at [2018] GLR 163 and noted in June). It upheld the President's appointment of the GECOM Chairman. According to press reports, the judges held that the submission of lists without engagement on the nominees could not produce a consensual candidate. The President was not obliged to choose from the lists, and in the absence of consensus he could appoint a person from the judicial category. The appellant indicated an appeal to the CCJ, which allowed it in June 2019.
The account of the Court of Appeal's decision is taken from press reports and has not been verified against a written judgment. The account of Titan is taken from the CCJ's judgment.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
