Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

The High Court on the GECOM Chairman's Qualifications and the CCJ on Confession Evidence and Bus Permits

July 2017

Published 16 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The acting Chief Justice ruled that the Constitution does not prefer judges for the chairmanship of the Elections Commission. The CCJ quashed convictions resting only on disputed oral confessions. It also found that a Belize transport board had frustrated a bus operator's legitimate expectation.

On 25 July, in Edwards and Haynes v The Queen [2017] CCJ 10 (AJ), the CCJ quashed two convictions from Barbados. The only evidence against the appellants was alleged oral confessions to police officers, which they disputed and had not acknowledged in writing. The Court held that the trial judge's directions under section 137 of the Evidence Act did not go far enough in warning the jury about the dangers of relying on such evidence.

On 26 July, in Gilharry v Transport Board [2017] CCJ 11 (AJ), the CCJ allowed a Belize bus operator's appeal. It declared that the Transport Board had not lawfully considered the renewal of his road service permit and had frustrated his legitimate expectation. It awarded him indemnity costs.

From the Guyana Courts

In Gaskin v Attorney General (17 July), the acting Chief Justice, Roxane George-Wiltshire, interpreted article 161(2) of the Constitution. That article governs the President's appointment of the Chairman of the Elections Commission from a list of six names submitted by the Leader of the Opposition. According to press reports, the court held that the categories of persons eligible (judges, former judges, persons qualified to be judges, and any other fit and proper person) carry equal weight, and that judges are not to be preferred. A nominee who is not a judge should have judge-like qualities. The press also reported that the court said the President should give reasons for rejecting a list. The Opposition Leader's third list was rejected and, in October, the President appointed a retired judge as Chairman under the proviso to article 161(2).

The account of Gaskin is taken from press reports and has not been verified against a written judgment. The accounts of the CCJ decisions are taken from the CCJ's judgments.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.