The CCJ declared that a breach of the right to trial within a reasonable time barred enforcement of the rest of a drugs sentence. In its original jurisdiction it held that Guyana's environmental tax on imported beverage containers breached the Revised Treaty. An order gave effect to tax information exchange with the United States.
On 31 May the Income Tax (United States of America Foreign Account Tax Compliance Exchange of Information) Order 2017 (Order No. 8) was gazetted.
On 4 May, in Bridgelall v Hariprashad [2017] CCJ 8 (AJ), reported at [2017] GLR 122, the CCJ granted special leave and affirmed the applicant's convictions in 2007 for possession of cocaine for trafficking. It ordered that his two five-year sentences run concurrently rather than consecutively. He had been freed in 2009 when the Full Court allowed his appeal, after serving 30 months in custody, and the prosecution's appeal then took years to be decided. The CCJ declared that his constitutional right to a fair hearing within a reasonable time had been breached, and it stayed any further enforcement of the rest of the prison sentences.
On 9 May, in SM Jaleel & Co Ltd v Co-operative Republic of Guyana [2017] CCJ 2 (OJ), reported at [2017] GLR 217, the CCJ in its original jurisdiction held that Guyana breached article 87(1) of the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas. It had imposed an environmental tax on imported non-returnable beverage containers that qualified for Community treatment. The claimants were entitled to repayment of the tax they paid from 7 March 2011 to 7 August 2015. Any passing on of the tax to customers did not unjustly enrich them, and they recovered 70 per cent of their costs.
From the Guyana Courts
The accounts of Bridgelall and SM Jaleel are taken from the CCJ's judgments and the reports at [2017] GLR 122 and 217.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
