The High Court ordered the Minister of Legal Affairs to appoint the governing board of the Deeds and Commercial Registries Authority. The CCJ explained when a trial judge must leave self-defence to a jury even if the accused has not raised it.
On 6 April, in Stanford v The Queen [2017] CCJ 7 (AJ), the CCJ dismissed an appeal from Barbados against a conviction for manslaughter arising from a fatal shooting. It held that the trial judge had not erred in failing to leave self-defence to the jury. The accused had relied entirely on accident. Where an accused gives no evidence of self-defence and his statements contain nothing from which it can reasonably be inferred, the judge must still examine the rest of the evidence to see whether the issue reasonably arises. Here it did not.
From the Guyana Courts
In Nandlall v Minister of Legal Affairs [2017] GLR 112 (19 April), Harnanan J made absolute an order nisi of mandamus requiring the Minister to appoint the Governing Board of the Deeds and Commercial Registries Authority. The Minister responsible for administering the Act had a duty to take active steps to appoint the Board, and the court must intervene when an aggrieved party asks it to uphold the rule of law. There had been no Board for some ten and a half months. The Minister had shown insufficient cause. Parliament amended the Board's composition in June.
The account of Nandlall is taken from the report at [2017] GLR 112. The account of Stanford is taken from the CCJ's judgment.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
