The High Court upheld paper committals under the Sexual Offences Act. The Full Court upheld a 2000 rights issue and bonus shares in Guyana Stockfeeds. The CCJ dismissed an attempt to appeal a Barbados magistrate's order out of time.
On 23 November, in Deane v Allamby [2016] CCJ 21 (AJ), the CCJ gave its reasons for dismissing on 31 October an appeal from Barbados. The appellant had sought to appeal out of time against a magistrate's order for possession, and the Court of Appeal had held that it could not extend the time for giving notice of appeal from the Magistrate's Court. The CCJ rejected the argument that the appeal to it was a nullity, because the Court of Appeal's decision turned on statutory interpretation. It confirmed that there is no statutory power to extend the seven-day time limit, but cautioned that the court keeps jurisdiction to extend time where that is needed to give effect to the constitutional right to a fair trial, for example after a national disaster. In any event no good reason had been shown for the delay, and the appeal had no real prospect of success. By consent, the property was to be vacated by 28 February 2017.
From the Guyana Courts
In Re an application under the Sexual Offences Act [2016] GLR 154 (4 November), Singh PJ discharged an order nisi of certiorari that an accused had obtained to quash his committal for trial. There was no allegation or evidence that the magistrate had failed to follow the procedure in the Sexual Offences Act. The paper committal procedure still allows an accused, after receiving the prosecution's evidence, to file his evidence in defence. The only question is whether there is a sufficient case to put him on trial. Nor had the magistrate breached article 153 of the Constitution by not referring the constitutional question to the High Court.
In Guyana Stockfeeds Inc v National Industrial and Commercial Investments Ltd [2016] GLR 159 (11 November), the Full Court held that the August 2000 notice of the extraordinary general meeting that approved an increase in authorised share capital complied with the Companies Act 1991. The four-for-one rights issue of December 2000 was not ultra vires, so the bonus shares were validly issued. No fiduciary duty owed by the directors to the shareholder, or breach of one, was established. The appeal was allowed in full, all of the trial judge's orders were vacated, and costs of $300,000 were awarded to the company.
In Rutherford v Lawrence [2016] GLR 171 (11 November), Singh PJ set aside a 2008 court order, obtained by fraud, under which a property at Plantation Providence on the East Bank of Demerara had been sold. The court declared the owners' 1987 transport valid and in force, found that the buyers had been unaware of the fraud, awarded the owners $1,000,000 in damages for fraud against the defendant who obtained the order, and restrained all three defendants from entering the land.
The accounts of the Sexual Offences Act application, Guyana Stockfeeds and Rutherford are taken from the reports at [2016] GLR 154, 159 and 171. The account of Deane is taken from the CCJ's judgment.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
