The High Court quashed the Guyana Energy Agency’s seizure of a vessel and its fuel cargo, and the Court of Appeal held that a trial judge must itemise each head of damages.
From the Guyana Courts
On 22 January, in Etwaroo v Guyana Energy Agency, the acting Chief Justice made absolute orders of certiorari and mandamus against the Guyana Energy Agency and its chief executive. They had seized and detained the M.V. Ocean Runner and its cargo of dieseline. The court held that there was no evidential basis for concluding that the unmarked petroleum cargo was for domestic use, so the seizure and detention were unlawful and ultra vires.
On 20 January, in Dukhi v Guyana Sugar Corporation, the Court of Appeal set aside an award of damages for injuries in a road collision. Itemising the various heads of damages is a duty of the trial judge, not a matter of discretion, and the award bore no resemblance to the proven claims. The court substituted itemised awards for special damages, loss of earning capacity and pain and suffering.
The accounts of Etwaroo and Dukhi are taken from the reports at [2015] GLR 7 and 3.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
