The CCJ held that Barbados had breached a Jamaican national’s right of entry under the Revised Treaty and that a mining company had no substantive legitimate expectation to a uranium licence. The Full Court relieved a party from the effect of an unless order, and the Court of Appeal ruled on appeals as of right to the CCJ.
On 4 October, in Myrie v State of Barbados [2013] CCJ 3 (OJ), the CCJ, in its original jurisdiction, declared that Barbados had breached the claimant’s right of entry under article 45 of the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas, read with the 2007 Conference Decision that Community nationals are entitled to an automatic stay of six months on arrival. Entry and stay must be both definite and free of harassment. It awarded Bds$2,240 in pecuniary damages and Bds$75,000 in non-pecuniary damages, with costs. It held that it lacked jurisdiction to grant relief for breaches of human rights treaties as such, though it may take international human rights law into account in developing Community law, and refused the other declarations sought.
On 30 October, in Pharsalus Inc v Commissioner of the Guyana Geology and Mines Commission [2013] CCJ 10 (AJ), the CCJ allowed the appeal in part. The Court of Appeal had made absolute all four orders nisi, giving the company a uranium licence over an area of 11,450 acres. The CCJ held that the company had no entitlement by way of substantive legitimate expectation to a uranium licence, and discharged the fourth order. The first three orders nisi stood, with the Commission substituted for the Commissioner as defendant, so that the company’s challenge to the proposed extension of another company’s licence to uranium can be tried on its merits. There was no order as to costs.
From the Guyana Courts
On 25 October, in Rutherford v Rai, the Full Court allowed an appeal where a judge had refused to consider a party’s reasons for missing the deadline in an unless order, treating the order as having become absolute. That drove him from the judgment seat. His affidavit in answer was deemed properly filed and the matter was remitted to the chamber judge.
On 25 and 31 October, in Attorney General v NH International Ltd, the Court of Appeal held that an appeal lies to the CCJ as of right only from a final decision of the Court of Appeal; interlocutory appeals require the CCJ’s special leave. Because the question to be decided related indirectly to an adjudicator’s award worth hundreds of millions of dollars, it granted the Attorney General leave to appeal as of right. On 21 April 2015 the CCJ dismissed the appeal, upholding the company’s objection that there had been no direct right of appeal to the Court of Appeal against the leave to enforce the award.
The accounts of the Guyana decisions are taken from the reports at [2013] GLR 436 and 453. The accounts of Myrie and Pharsalus, and the later outcome in NH International, are taken from the CCJ's judgments.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
