The CCJ rejected a constructive dismissal claim against a Barbados hotel. The High Court upheld the Competition and Consumer Affairs Commission’s market finding against Ogle Airport but quashed its investigation as procedurally unfair, and quashed the revocation of a re-migrant’s tax exemptions. The Court of Appeal refused a stay of execution in a dispute over DSL service.
On 21 February, in Sandy Lane Hotel Co Ltd v Laurayne [2013] CCJ 1 (AJ), on appeal from Barbados, the CCJ allowed the hotel’s appeal and held that the employee’s claim of constructive dismissal failed. By consent, the employee was ordered to pay the hotel’s costs in the CCJ and below, agreed at Bds$82,500.
From the Guyana Courts
On 8 February, in Re Ogle Airport Inc, the acting Chief Justice ruled on a challenge to the Competition and Consumer Affairs Commission’s decision to investigate and adjudicate a complaint by Air Services Ltd against the operator of Ogle Airport under the Competition and Fair Trading Act 2006. The Act sets a threshold of more than 40 per cent of the market but gives no criteria for defining the market, and Parliament had left that determination to the Commission. The court therefore declined to disturb the Commission’s finding of dominance, and held that the competence of its members could be questioned only by a direct challenge to their appointments. But section 7(9) of the Act requires hearings to be held in public, with hearings in camera only where the circumstances warrant, and every hearing had been held in camera. Nor had the company been given the opportunity to hear and cross-examine those who made adverse statements against it or to present evidence in rebuttal. Because the investigation did not meet the minimum requirements of procedural fairness, the order of certiorari quashing the decision to investigate and adjudicate the complaint was made absolute, the other orders nisi were discharged, and each party bore its own costs.
On 8 February, in Re Subhan, the acting Chief Justice quashed the Revenue Authority’s demand for taxes and its revocation of tax exemptions granted to a re-migrant. Although she had not presented her vehicle documents for inspection every six months, the Commissioner General had waived that breach and had verified that she was living in Guyana and complying with the conditions of the exemptions. The order of prohibition was discharged, so as not to bind the Authority in future legitimate enforcement, and each party bore its own costs.
On 22 February, in Guyana Telephone and Telegraph Co Ltd v Samuels, Roy JA refused to stay, pending appeal, a High Court judgment that the company had breached its contract with a customer by interfering with his use of its DSL internet service for VoIP calls, and the injunctions restraining further interference. The interim stay was discharged. The court must give full weight to the principle that there must be good reason to deprive a successful claimant of the fruits of his judgment, and the mere existence of an arguable ground of appeal is not such a reason.
The accounts of the Guyana decisions are taken from the reports at [2013] GLR 73, 84 and 91. The account of the Barbados appeal is taken from the CCJ's judgment.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
