The High Court refused a conservatory order against the former Presidents’ benefits law and held that accused persons were entitled to transcripts admitted at their preliminary inquiry.
From the Guyana Courts
On 5 January, in Trotman v Attorney General, the court refused a conservatory order against the legislation on benefits and facilities for former Presidents. The provision challenged had nothing to do with the pensions and gratuities covered by article 181(2) of the Constitution. The order sought would have affected former Presidents, who are private citizens not represented by the Attorney General, and they had been neither heard nor joined. The claim should also have been brought by originating summons rather than writ, as no facts were in dispute; the choice of the longer process showed that the matter was not urgent.
On 12 January the court refused the Director of Public Prosecutions’ application for prerogative orders arising from a preliminary inquiry. A preliminary inquiry does not serve only to decide whether there is a sufficient case; it also lets the accused know in advance the evidence they will have to meet at trial. Having admitted transcripts into evidence, the Chief Magistrate was bound by article 144(2)(c) of the Constitution to give the accused copies. The application was misconceived.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2012] GLR 21 and 29.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
