The High Court held that the Roads Act requires no hearing before an obstruction is removed, refused to quash the Public Service Commission’s decision not to fill the post of Chief Education Officer, and quashed the revocation of a firearm licence.
From the Guyana Courts
On 3 November, and in a companion case on 11 November, the acting Chief Justice discharged orders nisi that had halted the demolition of stalls at the Stabroek Market. Section 5(1) of the Roads Act makes no provision for the owner of an obstruction to be heard before the road officer removes it from the road reserve. If the Chief Works Officer had made a mistake of jurisdictional fact, which the vendors had not proved, their remedy lay in other proceedings. Costs of $30,000 were awarded against them.
On 11 November the court refused to quash the Public Service Commission’s decision not to fill the vacant office of Chief Education Officer, on an application by the officer who had acted in the post since 2005. The Commission had considered whether to make an appointment and decided not to, in the exercise of its discretion, and the court could not substitute its own. The applicant had sought certiorari, not mandamus to consider filling the office. The order nisi was discharged with $50,000 costs.
On 22 November the court quashed the revocation of a firearm licence by the Commander of A Division and made absolute an order of mandamus against the Commissioner of Police for the return of the firearm and licence; the mandamus against the Divisional Commander was discharged, since the firearm and licence were held by the police, not by him. The holder had not been charged with any offence involving the firearm, and the police had relied only on the revocation.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2011] GLR 328, 333, 334 and 336.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
