The High Court held that the offence of unlawful possession did not survive the presumption of innocence, the Court of Appeal refused leave to appeal to the CCJ from a refusal to extend time, and the High Court declined to interpret the Customs Act in the abstract.
From the Guyana Courts
On 29 April, on a question referred from a magistrate’s court, the acting Chief Justice held that the offence of unlawful possession under section 94(1) of the Summary Jurisdiction (Offences) Act could not survive the presumption of innocence. The offence, imported from the English Metropolitan Police Courts Act 1839, allowed conviction on possession and a reasonable suspicion held by the police, and required the defendant to prove the lawfulness of his possession. It had been impliedly repealed by article 10(2)(a) of the 1966 Constitution and was not an existing law saved by the 1980 Constitution, whose article 144(2)(a) also guarantees the presumption of innocence.
On 11 April the Court of Appeal refused leave to appeal to the CCJ from its own refusal to extend time for an appeal. The right of appeal is a creature of statute. Section 7 of the Caribbean Court of Justice Act allows an appeal with the Court of Appeal’s leave where a question of great general or public importance ought to be submitted to the CCJ, and this was not such a case.
In April the acting Chief Justice dismissed as misconceived an application asking the court to interpret the Fifth Schedule to the Customs Act, which governs the transaction value of imported goods. Academic interpretation is for legal scholars, not the court. If the Revenue Authority had ignored the Schedule, the remedy was an enforceable order, not an interpretation.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2011] GLR 127, 123 and 115.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
