Parliament passed the Judicial Review Act, the Contempt of Court Act and the Alternative Dispute Resolution Act and restructured sentencing for murder, and the CCJ reinstated an appeal that the Court of Appeal had dismissed on a finding of forgery.
On 21 October Parliament passed three Acts on the administration of justice. The Judicial Review Act 2010 (Act No. 23) provides for applications to the High Court for judicial review, with statutory grounds for relief, standing for applications justifiable in the public interest, remedies including certiorari, prohibition and mandamus, and a right to a statement of reasons for a decision. It was to come into force on a date appointed by the Minister; after the High Court ordered the Minister to act, it was deemed in force from 31 July 2018 (see the May and August 2018 dockets). The Contempt of Court Act 2010 (Act No. 25) replaces the earlier Contempt of Court Act, defines contempt of court and makes it punishable, for an individual, by a fine of up to $250,000 or imprisonment for up to three months and, for a company or other association, by a fine of up to $750,000, makes it contempt to obtain or disclose a jury’s deliberations or to record sound in court without leave, and protects innocent publication and fair and accurate reports of proceedings. The Alternative Dispute Resolution Act 2010 (Act No. 24) allows a court to refer a matter before it, other than criminal proceedings, for mediation or neutral evaluation, whether or not the parties consent, and comes into force on a date appointed by the Attorney General.
The Criminal Law (Offences) (Amendment) Act 2010 (Act No. 21), passed on 14 October, replaces section 100 of the Criminal Law (Offences) Act. Murder of members of the security forces, prison officers and judicial or legal officers acting in their duties, of witnesses, parties or jurors because of that status, in the course of robbery, burglary, arson of a dwelling or a sexual offence, or for reward, is punishable under new section 100A by death or life imprisonment. Other murders carry life imprisonment or a term of not less than fifteen years.
On 14 October, in [2010] CCJ 4 (AJ), the CCJ allowed an appeal from Guyana after granting special leave on 4 October. The Court of Appeal had dismissed an appeal on the footing that the notice of appeal bore a forged signature, because the appellant’s name appeared on it in capital letters. That was wrong. The attorney’s signature was enough to make the notice effective, the name may simply have identified the appellant, and before any finding of forgery the allegation must at least be put, proved by evidence and answered. The case was remitted to the Court of Appeal to be heard on the merits, with costs against the respondent, who had defended the Court of Appeal’s decision to the end.
From the Guyana Courts
On 1 October the acting Chief Justice held, on an application by the Guyana Labour Union concerning an arbitrator’s award in a dispute with the Mayor and City Council of Georgetown, that the court has no jurisdiction to alter or amend an arbitrator’s award. Although not an order or judgment of the court, the award could, with leave, be enforced as one; but leave had not specifically been sought, and the court declined to grant it.
The accounts of the Acts are taken from their texts as published by the Parliament of Guyana. The account of the CCJ appeal is taken from the CCJ’s judgment and the report at [2010] GLR 244, and that of the arbitration from the report at [2010] GLR 236.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
