The Full Court struck out appeals from a Rice Assessment Committee that had decided nothing on the merits, the High Court found paternity on the deceased’s own admissions, and it refused to cure one fraud by ordering another.
From the Guyana Courts
On 18 January the Full Court (the acting Chief Justice and Ramlal J) struck out appeals by the Public Trustee from a Rice Assessment Committee, which had declined to hear applications because the parties were not landlord and tenant. There can be no appeal by way of rehearing where there has been no determination on the merits. The real dispute was whether the respondents owned the rice lands, a question the Committee had no jurisdiction to decide, and the Full Court as an appellate court could make no finding on whether the Committee had erred.
On 26 January the acting Chief Justice declared, without scientific evidence, that a man who died intestate and unmarried was the father of the plaintiff, on the strength of his admissions to his mother and brothers that he was responsible for her mother’s pregnancy. The plaintiff was entitled to a one-third share of the estate, and the administratrix was restrained from vesting or dealing with the properties without recognising that share and ordered to account.
On 27 January the court ordered defendants to give up possession of land that the first defendant had agreed to buy from a man who did not own it at the time and only later became administrator of the owner’s estate. An earlier order had directed him to pass transport to the defendant, but compliance would have been a fraud on the estate. He had defrauded the defendant, but the court could not remedy that fraud by an order perpetuating another on the estate.
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2010] GLR 1, 6 and 10.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
