Parliament passed the Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters Act; the Full Court quashed narcotics convictions and questioned reverse-onus presumptions; and the Court of Appeal reversed a trespass ruling and ordered NICIL to pay a long-delayed pension.
The Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters Act 2009 (Act No. 38), passed on 3 December, gives effect to the Commonwealth scheme for mutual assistance in criminal matters and provides for assistance between Guyana and countries with which it has a treaty on such assistance, through a designated central authority.
From the Guyana Courts
On 9 December the Full Court allowed appeals against narcotics convictions and set aside the convictions and sentences. Even accepting that the appellant had joint control of the premises, there was no evidence that he knew the substances were there, and control of premises must not be equated with control of things found on them. The court also pointed out that provisions like section 5(2) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (Control) Act 1988, which reverse the burden of proof on an ingredient of an offence, have been successfully challenged elsewhere as violating the presumption of innocence, yet magistrates continue to rely on the presumption of their constitutionality.
On 16 December the Court of Appeal reversed a trial judge’s dismissal of a claim for trespass to the person. The judge’s findings were unsupported by the evidence and unreasonable: even if one defendant’s blow that disarmed the appellant was in defence of another, the evidence showed that the attack continued after he was disarmed and on the ground. The court awarded $150,000 in general damages.
Also on 16 December, in Ramsahoye v Linden Mining Enterprise Ltd, a Justice of Appeal in chambers dismissed a stay of execution sought against Mr Ramsahoye, a former employee of the company, joined National Industrial and Commercial Investments Ltd (NICIL) as a respondent, and ordered NICIL to pay him his monthly pension of US$2,001.72 from 1 August 2009, with the Registrar authorised to direct payment from NICIL’s funds in default. The court described a grave injustice in the proceedings taken to resist a Court of Appeal judgment of March 2004. On 20 July 2018 the Court of Appeal discharged those orders, holding that the judge in chambers had exceeded his jurisdiction ([2018] GLR 270), and in May 2019 the CCJ refused special leave to appeal (see May 2019).
The accounts of the Acts are taken from their texts as published by the Parliament of Guyana. The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2009] GLR 328, 339 and 347, and [2018] GLR 270.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
