Parliament passed the 2009 Appropriation Act; the CCJ granted a cement producer special leave to sue the Caribbean Community; and the Court of Appeal upheld a registered proprietor’s title and ruled on murder indictments after a manslaughter committal.
The Appropriation Act 2009 (Act No. 7), passed on 26 February, authorises the issue from the Consolidated Fund of up to $118,483,761,000 for the expenditure of Guyana in the fiscal year ending 31 December 2009, under article 218 of the Constitution and section 17 of the Fiscal Management and Accountability Act 2003.
On 5 February, in Trinidad Cement Ltd v The Caribbean Community [2009] CCJ 2 (OJ), the CCJ granted Trinidad Cement Ltd special leave under article 222 to bring proceedings against the Community itself over the suspension of the common external tariff on cement. The Community has full juridical personality under article 228(1) and can be sued for the acts of COTED, one of its organs, and of the Secretary-General acting on COTED’s behalf. The discretion to suspend the tariff arises only if the conditions in article 83(2) are met, and on the material before the Court it appeared prima facie that they had not been. Costs were reserved.
From the Guyana Courts
On 2 February the Court of Appeal allowed an appeal by a registered proprietor of land and set aside the trial judge’s orders, which had declared his transfer of title null and void. A registered proprietor’s title can be defeated only for fraud, and there was no evidence of it. The respondent’s earlier agreement to buy the land gave, at most, an interest that was neither registered nor protected under section 70(2)(a) of the Land Registry Act, and the proprietor’s knowledge of such an interest did not amount to fraud. By consent, there was no order as to costs. On 15 April the CCJ dismissed a further appeal, affirming the Court of Appeal (see April).
On 3 February the Court of Appeal held that the Director of Public Prosecutions may indict an accused for murder although the magistrate committed him for manslaughter, where the admissible evidence in the depositions supports the more serious charge (section 113(2) of the Criminal Law (Procedure) Act). The High Court may review and quash an indictment that is not legal and proper. The court nonetheless found that the trial judge’s direction on provocation might have left the jury confused, and substituted a conviction for manslaughter with a sentence of twelve years.
The accounts of the Acts are taken from their texts as published by the Parliament of Guyana. The account of the CCJ decision is taken from the CCJ’s judgment and the report at [2009] GLR 69, and those of the Court of Appeal decisions from the reports at [2009] GLR 44 and 49.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
