The Court of Appeal held that the Elections Commission must share scrutineer funding among the opposition parties in proportion to their strength in the National Assembly, set aside a declaration of title and refused leave to appeal to the CCJ in a debenture dispute; the acting Chief Justice held that the termination of a ferry contract was a matter for private law.
From the Guyana Courts
On 4 June the acting Chief Justice discharged orders nisi obtained by a ferry operator whose contract to run the Kurupukari Crossing ferry was ended when Cabinet awarded the service, with the Linden–Lethem road works, to another company. Unless a public authority’s decision to make or end a contract for services is controlled by statute, the general public law duty to act in the public interest does not attract judicial review, which cannot replace private law remedies for breach of contract. Costs of $30,000 went to the respondents.
On 16 June the Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by the Guyana Elections Commission against orders of certiorari and mandamus obtained in the High Court by two representatives of opposition parties in the National Assembly. The Commission had decided on 25 September 2007 not to allocate proportionately among the combined parliamentary opposition parties the money Parliament provided for their scrutineers in the house-to-house registration exercise. Certiorari lies against the decisions of the Elections Commission and its Chairman, and the prerogative writs are not confined to judicial or quasi-judicial proceedings. In deciding how the scrutineers of the combined opposition parties were to be paid, the Commission had to act fairly, reasonably and justly; paying the money to a single opposition party would be unfair and beyond its authority, and an allocation proportionate to the parties’ numerical strength in the National Assembly met those requirements. The applicants had sufficient interest to bring the proceedings, and the Commission’s objections based on the Crown Office Rules 1906 were rejected. The appeal was dismissed with costs of $150,000 to the respondents.
On 20 June the Court of Appeal set aside a Commissioner of Title’s declaration that a petitioner had acquired a sublot by adverse possession, because the Commissioner had not considered whether her occupation was single and exclusive, whether she had the intention to possess, or the status of the other occupants. Each party bore its own costs.
On 24 June the Court of Appeal refused LOP Investments Ltd leave to appeal to the CCJ from its February decision. Although the value in dispute exceeded $1,000,000, the court held that the case raised no genuinely disputable issue and no question of great general or public importance. On 1 May 2009 the CCJ granted special leave, holding that the Court of Appeal ought to have granted leave as of right (see May 2009).
The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2008] GLR 139, 146, 154 and 161.
This commentary is general information, not legal advice.
