Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

A Public Service Circular Partly Unconstitutional, Leave to Appeal to the CCJ as a Poor Person and a Remedy for Delay Without a Stay

May 2008

Published 17 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The acting Chief Justice struck down part of a Public Service Ministry circular and ordered a single charge and a prompt preliminary inquiry for a long-delayed accused, and the CCJ let an appellant proceed as a poor person.

On 16 May, in [2008] CCJ 4 (AJ), the CCJ gave its reasons for having granted an appellant, in January, leave to appeal as a poor person and for quashing the Court of Appeal’s requirement that she lodge $100,000 as security for costs, so that she could take advantage of the leave to appeal the Court of Appeal had already granted. The Court held that it has a residual power to make such an order, to be used only when necessary to eliminate a real risk of a miscarriage of justice. Had the application been coupled with one for special leave to appeal, the Court would have granted both, but as both parties were impecunious it chose not to require the appellant to make a further application for special leave. There was no order as to costs. The CCJ allowed her appeal on 8 October 2009 (see October 2009).

From the Guyana Courts

On 16 May the acting Chief Justice declared paragraph 8 of a Public Service Ministry circular unconstitutional, on an application by a public servant and the Guyana Public Service Union. Nothing in the circular was discriminatory under article 149, and the executive may decide whether a public office should be abolished or filled and whether substantively or by acting appointment, while the Public Service Commission decides who is appointed. But paragraph 8, requiring the Ministry’s prior approval, was too wide and inconsistent with articles 201(1) and 226(1), and only to that extent was the circular unconstitutional. There was no order as to costs.

On 19 May the acting Chief Justice declared that the right of an accused, charged with two murders in April 2000, to a hearing within a reasonable time under article 144(1) had been infringed, as no preliminary inquiry had begun by 2008. It is the State’s responsibility to provide an efficient and properly staffed legal system. The court ordered a single charge for both murders to be substituted and a preliminary inquiry to begin within 21 days, but held that the breach did not require a stay or dismissal of the charges. The accused was released on conditions, including weekly reporting to the police and a $200,000 deposit as security for his appearance, with costs of $50,000 to him.

The account of the CCJ decision is taken from the CCJ’s judgment and the report at [2008] GLR 117, and those of the High Court decisions from the reports at [2008] GLR 109 and 124.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.