Skip to content

Make an enquiryTel +592 226 0891Monday–Friday 8:30am–4:30pm

Fraser & Housty, Attorneys-at-Law emblemFraser & HoustyAttorneys-at-Law

The Monthly Docket

No Duty of Care to a Riot Victim, No Right Not to Be Transferred and a Receiver’s Powers Under Debentures

February 2008

Published 17 November 2026Fraser & Housty

The High Court dismissed a businessman’s claim against the State for losses in the 1999 Regent Street riots and a public servant’s challenge to her transfer, and the Court of Appeal upheld a bank’s debentures.

From the Guyana Courts

On 22 February the High Court dismissed a claim by a businessman for losses suffered in the riots along Regent Street on 5 March 1999, during the disturbances that followed the 1997 elections. Article 32 of the Constitution, which declares the State’s duty to address and prevent crime, is declaratory and not enforceable in itself. Although the court found that police patrols had been sporadic and reactive, the plaintiff had shown nothing about himself or his circumstances that gave rise to a duty of care owed to him beyond that owed to other businessmen and members of the public in the area, and his claim also failed on grounds of public policy. Nominal costs of $10,000 were ordered against him.

On 4 February the acting Chief Justice dismissed a constitutional motion by a typist/clerk at the Regional Democratic Council of Region 2, whom the Regional Executive Officer had asked to give up a Council house she occupied and whom the Permanent Secretary of the Ministry of Labour, Human Services and Social Security had transferred to the Ministry’s head office in Georgetown. A public officer has no fundamental right not to be transferred within the Public Service, so a claim of unlawful or unreasonable transfer does not lie under article 153. The other acts of harassment she alleged, beyond asking her to leave the house, serving a notice to quit and dismantling her fence, were private acts of a public officer done in his private rather than his official capacity. Costs of $50,000 were awarded against her.

On 20 February the Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by LOP Investments Ltd against Demerara Bank Ltd. It was the substance, not the form, of the security instruments that mattered: they were debentures, a receiver appointed under them was the company’s agent, and the company would be liable for interfering with the receiver’s duties. Nothing showed that it would be inequitable for the bank to insist on its strict legal rights. The CCJ later granted the company special leave and, on 10 August 2009, dismissed its appeal, affirming the Court of Appeal (see May and August 2009).

The accounts of the decisions are taken from the reports at [2008] GLR 27, 6 and 17.

This commentary is general information, not legal advice.